Well when you cite the low critic scores it implies you are giving them credit and taking their opinons into consideration.
Also, who are the "most people says it sucks" if not the critics? I pointed out Yahoo! Users and BOM users have it at a 'B' score. Heck even RT community is 45% a full 40pts higher. I'm not saying Season of the Witch
is Oscar bait but it was fun, imo.
Most people also watch AI
, Jersey Shore
and other reality crap. If I used that as a baramoter of cool I'd never actually see stuff I liked.