Is this the first time he's ever liked a movie? I haven't seen all of them, but I don't remember him ever liking a movie before. And yes, they're more entertaining when he hates the movie. If only the TNG cast had made one more for him to eviscerate.
He was ok with Avatar. I don't think he thought it was the masterpiece everyone else thought it was.
I liked the review. I had the same problem with the convenience of Kirk being on the same ice planet as Scotty & Old Spock.
But Chris Pine is so hot, the movie could be about nothing and I would still watch.