View Single Post
Old May 17 2010, 08:28 PM   #113
TOS Purist
Commander
 
TOS Purist's Avatar
 
Location: TOS Era
Send a message via AIM to TOS Purist Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to TOS Purist
Re: Where did Spock go?

Dukhat wrote: View Post
the OP, who is a self-proclaimed TOS purist, who for one reason or another simply cannot accept any Star Trek productions past TMP as "legitimate, official" Star Trek, [...] He will never, ever accept anything that doesn't fit his own take on ST.
No, Warped9 would accept newer forms of Star Trek as canon, but only if they bothered to make themselves internally consistent instead of constantly ignoring or rewriting TOS. And he's not the only TOS purist around here...

Dukhat wrote: View Post
Excuse me? Star Trek '09 was a huge success, making the most money of any Trek film ever. How is that a "failure?"
He doesn't mean failing FINANCIALLY. He meant it failed in terms of adhering to what little bits of canon it should have adhered to. Read his post! I'm tired of people saying that ST09 failed for this or that reason, and then someone else barges in and yells "IT DIDN'T FAIL IT MADE A LOT OF MONEY LOL" when nobody was talking about box office returns.
__________________
All your Trek are belong to non-canon - except for TOS!
TOS Purist is offline   Reply With Quote