May work fine for you, but it's total nonsense to me.
What is nonsense here is your inability to deal with a fucking movie
that doesn't go in the exact direction that you want it to, and the need to contrive your own "real" version to satisfy yourself.
I don't have to contrive anything. Abrams and his writers did it all simply by how they chose to write the film.
You're no different than someone who maintains he sees four lights when anyone with a clear mind sees only three are there.