View Single Post
Old April 14 2010, 04:36 AM   #21
Sci
Admiral
 
Sci's Avatar
 
Location: State of Maryland/District of Columbia
Re: was ezri right in Tacking into the Wind - are Klingons hypocrites?

Kai Winn wrote: View Post
do you want to say religions are beneficial? 'false profits', two ferengi set themselves up as gods on a primitive planet to benefit no one but themselves. the bajorans, setting up some sort of wormhole aliens as gods,
And who's to say that the Wormhole Aliens aren't gods? After all, a god is by definition not a creature native to one's planet -- and so's an alien. All gods are by definition also extraterrestrial life-forms (or, if you will, extra-Bajoran life-forms). And certainly everyone agrees that they're native to the Bajoran Wormhole, whether they be gods or aliens.

Really, where's the contradiction between their being gods and their being aliens?

and claiming they want bajor to live in an oppressive cast society.
There is no evidence whatsoever that the Bajoran Church required that caste system.

i don't see any benefits other than for the members of the high castes, and those who claim their power to decide the fate of bajor is given to them by the prophets. centuries ago, the bajorans were more advanced then humans, but while humans threw all that trash overboard and established the federation, bajor remained trapped in a dark age, and became an easy prey for an aggressive species.
There is no evidence whatsoever that Bajorans were "trapped in a dark age;" being conquered by a hostile foreign imperialist does not mean you're primitive.

Nor is there any evidence whatsoever that the Bajoran religion is responsible for the Bajorans' apparently relatively static rate of technological development. Different cultures develop technology at different rates, and one going slower and one going faster does not make one culture better or worse than others -- nor is such a rate necessarily linked to religiosity.

if starfleet has nothing but contempt for the pointless mumbojumbo which religions are, i certainly agree.
If Starfleet has nothing but contempt for religion, then it's not living up to its so-called IDIC respects for all cultures, and is as hypocritical as some claim the Klingons are.
__________________
This dream must end, this world must know:
We all depend on the beast below.
Sci is offline   Reply With Quote