Voted no because I don't believe that all the battle of the Dominion War need to be redo.
For example I don't think you need to do anything to the USS Centaur battle, the fake damaged Defiant
bait battle, the Rotarrans
strike on the Monac shipyards, the First Battle of Chin'toka, Martok's raid on the (Trelka V?) starbase, the Breen attacking the stolen attack ship and destroying it over Cardassia...which is all I can name at this point.
Some do need work. The "Call to Arms" battle maybe just a bit of work to have some larger Dominion and Cardassian ships blow up as well and to get rid of the attack ship attack on the Defiant
laying mines, I think it was stock footage of two of three Jem'Hadar attack ships diving and firing...maybe stock footage of Defiant
Operation Return is a tough one. I'd like to see more ships exploding and maybe having a stronger initial charge other then just seeing the Defiant
destroy one or two ships but having the initial contact point appearing more like when the Klingon's arrive, though I guess that would take away from that later scene.
The Second battle of Chin'toka is fine I think. Or at least I can't think of anything really needed.
Battle of Cardassia I'd rework quite a bit. A more grand launch from DS9 instead of the reuse from Tears
, a wider shot and see a truly massive fleet. I think the Defiant
was at the head of the formation in tears
, I'd place it back much like in Favors the Bold
. I'd also drop the entering Chin'toka but without the planet in the background shot for something original, maybe also include a shot of the Dominion fleet, though it wouldn't be static but have ships moving into position. I'd definitely drop all the reused footage, especially the SoA
stuff, which stands out too much given it shows a much tighter engagement while all the rest shows its far more spread out with small groups engaging each other.
Not exactly sure what I'd do but maybe something with short scenes that focus on a side from all the various sides. One of the Defiant
attacking someone, then a Klingon ship, a Romulan ship, a Dominion ship, a Cardassian ship, a Breen ship (maybe not in that order and a mix of attacking and seeing them get destroyed).
Once we get to Cardassia I'd keep pretty much the same thing but maybe add an extra detail and have Dominion and Breen ships visible bombarding the surface in the background just to add to the "They're killing Cardassians!" factor. After seeing that scene I desperately wanted to have the two sides once again engage. Imagine being a Cardassian and having to watch your homeworld burn while the Feds, Roms and Klings tell you to wait. You would be pissed and no doubt thinking that the slowness to act is the allies messing with Cardassians just one last time. No doubt the Roms and Klingons did not shed a tear as they watched...well, we know the Klingons didn't. Martok was happily toasting over their bodies, we probably cut out just before we broke into a merry Klingon shanty. Anyway, I'd love to work the battle back in just to readd a sense of desperation to Kira and Garak to get the Founder to surrender. Throw in some short scenes of the battle and have Kira call for Odo as the Defiant
is dealing out death and have Odo link with her as her final orbital defences are breaking and that she is about to have dozens of Klingons and Romulans marching on her position, throw in a bit of self-preservation into the mix of why she surrendered.
To conclude, I would make a few adjustments if I could...