View Single Post
Old September 13 2009, 06:51 AM   #71
TOS Purist
TOS Purist's Avatar
Location: TOS Era
Send a message via AIM to TOS Purist Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to TOS Purist
Re: TOS' U.S.S. Valiant and Farragut....

JuanBolio wrote: View Post
I don't think so. Even in the 60's they knew it was impossible to go faster than light under Newtonian thrust. Even the name "warp drive" implies its a field drive, not a rocket.
Well, there are theories to either effect to whether or not it's impossible to go faster than light under Newtonian thrust...although the time dilation effect due to speed under Einstein's relativity has proved itself true in some cases, it's still open to debate (a debate I hope to avoid in this thread...).

Warp drive doesn't really imply a field...Matt Jefferies famously said "What the hell is warp drive?" when Roddenberry told him how the Enterprise went faster than light, and I'm sure he had "warp drive" in mind when he developed the nacelles. Even so, they're obviously not field emitters and have a distinct front and back.

Maybe if you want to stick with the "field" idea, you could say that the field is created behind the ship by the ends of the nacelles, like the engines in Star Trek 2009 seem to do.
All your Trek are belong to non-canon - except for TOS!
TOS Purist is offline   Reply With Quote