Gary Sebben wrote:
The CG renders are pretty obvious. They're the ones with way to much detail visible despite the distance of the lens. They do look like cartoons.
Since you seem to be able to tell what's CG and what's miniature...
Can you tell what elements in this image are CG?
I can, but that's only because I've seen the elements separately ... you can't really tell because the miniature elements have been so crapped on in the 2K that they might as well be whole cloth mediocre CG.
EDIT ADDON: oh yeah, was your post made just to tick off the poster before yours, who rightfully would like the thread to contain info about TNG ReMastered?
THAT is the real crime of it all ... people expect miniatures to not look great because after scanning at 2K and comping, they don't look any better than CG.
Do these shots at full 35mm rez and you'd see great miniatures and crappy cg ships