View Single Post
Old May 19 2009, 03:44 PM   #67
Qonos
Captain
 
Qonos's Avatar
 
Location: Long Pond Pa
Re: Could we Trekkers have saved the Trek XI script? [SPOILERS]

flemm wrote: View Post
Peter the Younger wrote: View Post
The box office receipts would suggest they were right.
They suggest the movie got a lot of things right, which I believe it did. They don't, however, suggest the film is above criticism or that it could not be improved upon.

Peter the Younger wrote: View Post
Yeah, none of them are dummies, I'm sure they probably did sit down and say, "well some people won't like this at all." But it those people represent less than 10% of the core fanbase, and you bring in more than enough new fans to compensate, well, that's business.
I think it is difficult to argue that having Nimoy in the film was an important draw for new fans. Since much of the plot is contrived in order to have his character around, I think it is quite possible that the film would have been even more successful as a straight-forward reboot with no time-travel and a more elegant plot.
there is nothing in this world, made by man that cannot be improved upon.
__________________
This post is brought to you by The Soylent Green Biscuit company. Soylent Green our people have GREAT Taste.
Qonos is offline   Reply With Quote