Uggh... I'm horrible at grading movies. It's like choosing my favorite kid. I'll give it my best attempt....
The Motion Picture/ Wrath of Khan (A+) My favorites. These are easily the best films of the bunch.
The Undiscovered Country/First Contact/ Star Trek (2009): (A-) My... second favorites! Fun space adventures, all.
The Search For Spock/Voyage Home/Final Frontier/Generations: (B) Even the bad Trek movies are fun to watch... am I being to generous?
Insurrection/Nemesis: (F) Okay, most
of the bad Trek movies are fun to watch.