View Single Post
Old May 15 2009, 05:03 PM   #3
Re: A scene that I don't understand

digger wrote: View Post
I hope I post this correctly, as a post regarding a seperate topic I made 2 days ago somehow disappeared.

Anyway-- in the scenes where Kirk is speaking with Spock Prime, I believe toward the end, right before the beam out, Kirk says to Spock Prime something to the effect of, "You coming back in time. You cheated." Spock Prime responds with something like, "Something I learned from a old friend."

This whole exchange doesn't make much sense to me. I think I understand what the writers are trying to imply with this scene: that Spock Prime's solution to the Nero problem was no different than Kirk's solution to the Kobayashi Maru.

However, Spock Prime didn't come back in time intentionally. And even not taking that into account, now that Spock Prime is in the past, he is not trying to change anything (save for putting the Kirk/Spock friendship back on track).

So going back in time isn't his solution to anything. It's just what happened as a result of his actions.

Am I missing something else here? Can someone please clear it up for me if I am?

I took it as a glib reference to Star Trek 4: The Voyage Home. And on the note that Spock did not come back intentionally I agree with you, that whole scene seemed somewhat contrived. Yet another plot hole I guess.
Ransak is offline   Reply With Quote