I want to see something completely different and new, I don't want retreads of religious canon.
I would much prefer to see something where going in I have absolutely no clue about anyone. I want it all to be a surprise and new.
A new alien species maybe, anything but that which has already been.
How could a new alien species show up without time travel. The area of space within the Federation's range in the movie time period has already been well explored by the TNG era.