I've seen the movie but I honestly can't decide. I'll be seeing it again tonight so maybe i'll have my mind made up.
I'm in two minds about this movie. The movie loving side of me very much enjoyed the film. It had many great and memorable moments.
The Trekkie side of me on the other hand perhaps wanted this movie to be something else than it was. That side of me also saw a lot of flaws.
Trek might for me be this year's Indiana Jones KOTC. I grew to love that movie, but I had to see it a couple of times.