Just got back and I voted excellent. Saw it on IMAX and man it beautiful!!!!
A few nitpicks but not big enough to change my vote:
Rapid rise through the ranks (understandable from a story/pacing standpoint)
The status of the Romulans was a bit murky. Did Pike know they were Vulcan off shoots?
Delta Vegas location ( though what someone said up thread about Vulcans destruction being representational in Spocks meld makes sense.)
Overall it was great, the audience clapped at the end. My non trekkie wife gave it an A.
On the writing side: Nice to see they took chances rather than retreading well covered ground. Great characterization and a nice blend of old and new catch phrases.