Jude Law - I don't know that particular movie, but he is the only really good looking, handsome guy in that collection.
Well, if you'd read the OP, it isn't just about looks. It's about who you want to spend Christmas with, from the list of Christmas movies.
Oh, and let me add one entry completely from left fied:
John Cusack and Oliver Platt in the dark but hilarious "Ice Harvest"