View Single Post
Old October 15 2008, 02:16 PM   #22
ST-One
Vice Admiral
 
Location: Germany - with UHC since the early 1900s
Re: The "original" Ten-Forward

Probert wrote: View Post
Undead wrote: View Post
When Andrew Probert was doing initial designs on the Galaxy class, he had envisioned differently what eventually became Ten-Forward (which he dislikes, because he feels it's not really proportional to the saucer).
Quite true. As you can see, the saucer rim is way too small to accommodate that ridiculous set. It is a bit hard for me to understand why Berman insisted on stuffing that room in there when I totally provided many sizable window alcoves alluding to places of large social gatherings: restaurants, lounges, etc.



Below, you can see the windows provided for an Officer's Lounge which would have been perfect for a '10-forward'-sized space...



... but Producer Bob Justman had that set of windows (and many others) divided into smaller window sets, like the resulting odd block of windows below the saucer's shuttle bay.

Frustrating? Indeed, but I'm not the only person whose designs were/are not understood by "those in charge".

Andrew-

PS: A good example of the actual blue & green panel coloring.
It would have been so great to have seen your version of these saucer-rim-rooms, but I think these large windows looks better divided into smaller ones...
But at least this little change didn't fuck your layout for the ship as that idiotic 10-Forward-set did.
ST-One is offline   Reply With Quote