We should just start making up rumors here and see if they get picked up elsewhere.
Robert Downey, Jr. -- Riddler
Jack Black -- Penguin
Ben Stiller -- Mad Hatter
Matthew McConaughey -- Deadshot
Tom Cruise -- Hugo Strange
Nick Nolte -- Rupert Thorne
Danny McBride -- Harvey Bullock
Steve Coogan -- Creeper
Good idea. I heard Spaceman Spiff
was going to be the Riddler, and I'm going to play the Mad Hatter.