An Above Average for me.
Visually it was one of the most striking pictures of this year. The creatures, the contraptions, the fight scenes.. all at the top of the class and everything you come to expect from a Del Toro fantasy movie.
However the story couldn't quite match the fantastic pictures. It wasn't bad but somehow it didn't quite connect all the beautiful single scenes they way they should be connected.
However it is still a definite candidate for my DVD collection.