Of course she's attractive. What she lacks is stunning beauty. In the bygone days of black & white film and heavy makeup, screen testing was much more important. It's how they sifted through the many beautiful women to find the one that stood out projected on screen. The consensus I'm reading is that Maggie doesn't test well.
Go ahead and post that nerd pic every time you disagree. It's in our nature to be critical this way. It's our own standard we're exhibiting.
Sideways from me.