SFWA has deemed the script eligible, even if there is still some question of its legal status to a group of the members, myself included. But the script has been deemed eligible according to the Board's interpretation of the rules as they stand now.
And Ken, please remember that there are a lot more people than Keith who were involved in this. I was actually the person who brought it to his attention. So, if you're going to snark on anyone, I'm
the one you should be aiming at, not Keith. He just became the public face of the controversy instead of me. But I'm the one who got it going.