The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Deep Space Nine (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=40)
-   -   Where do Trill symbionts come from? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=98109)

Captrek July 6 2009 01:49 AM

Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Where do Trill symbionts come from? How do they reproduce?

Also, did the symbionts evolve inside humanoid hosts, or did they evolve as an independent species and later develop the ability to bond with a host?

CaptainStoner July 6 2009 01:51 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
A stork brings them, of course.

Plecostomus July 6 2009 02:01 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
They are a product of the Eugenics Wars. They were developed by Lowes to ensure brand loyalty, but after the Dark Army Of Walmart triumphed they were exiled to deep space aboard a DY-100 sleeper ship, which got sucked down a wormhole and it crashed on the Trill homeworld.

Captrek July 6 2009 02:04 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
And you guys wonder why Pocket Books won’t publish your stories.

CaptainStoner July 6 2009 02:09 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Not if we make the DY-100 sleeper ship a stork.

Plecostomus July 6 2009 02:22 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Quote:

CaptainStoner wrote: (Post 3157367)
Not if we make the DY-100 sleeper ship a stork.

The S.S. Stork. :techman:


Also: Joined Trills have can suffer from fatal dissolution if they eat too much salt, and they have an unstoppable (and fatal) fascination with small tins of beer.

Captrek July 6 2009 02:25 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
On a related note, why would it be so devastating to Trill society if it became known that they have a lot more hosts physically capable of hosting symbionts than they have symbionts? They’re a reasonably mature and democratic society, aren’t they? Aren’t they capable of coming up with an appropriate process for deciding who gets the symbionts, and enforcing that process?

And how many people have known this secret? How did they convince the public (what kind of evidence did they fake) that only very few Trills were capable of hosting, and how did hundreds of people (or was it thousands? or more?) manage to keep such a huge secret without anybody ever letting anything slip?

CaptainStoner July 6 2009 02:25 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Norm from Cheers was a Trill?

RichMerk July 6 2009 02:31 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Quote:

CaptainStoner wrote: (Post 3157320)
A stork brings them, of course.

A stork symbiote brings them. :)

Symbiotes always seemed kind of a problem to me. They are always shown as needing delicate surgery to install/uninstall, and that just doesn't seem something that would evolve naturally.

Or maybe the symbiotes can blend with hosts naturally, but the mortality rate was very high so the Trill developed medical methods to increase the survivability of both symbiote and host.

Kestrel July 6 2009 03:34 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Quote:

captrek wrote: (Post 3157407)
On a related note, why would it be so devastating to Trill society if it became known that they have a lot more hosts physically capable of hosting symbionts than they have symbionts? Theyíre a reasonably mature and democratic society, arenít they? Arenít they capable of coming up with an appropriate process for deciding who gets the symbionts, and enforcing that process?

And how many people have known this secret? How did they convince the public (what kind of evidence did they fake) that only very few Trills were capable of hosting, and how did hundreds of people (or was it thousands? or more?) manage to keep such a huge secret without anybody ever letting anything slip?

Worlds of DS9: Trill: Unjoined goes into detail exploring Trill society and answers a lot of these questions. In short, even mature and democratic societies don't stop people being greedy and thinking they deserve symbionts. Verad wouldn't be the only one willing to kill for the social and mental advantage of Joining. Also, Trill society and history is incredibly steeped in keeping secrets and hiding shame, to the point that entire swaths of history are forgotten.

Quote:

RichMerk wrote: (Post 3157425)
Quote:

CaptainStoner wrote: (Post 3157320)
A stork brings them, of course.

A stork symbiote brings them. :)

Symbiotes always seemed kind of a problem to me. They are always shown as needing delicate surgery to install/uninstall, and that just doesn't seem something that would evolve naturally.

Or maybe the symbiotes can blend with hosts naturally, but the mortality rate was very high so the Trill developed medical methods to increase the survivability of both symbiote and host.

I don't recall if Trill: Unjoined ever definitively answered this question, of where exactly the symbiotic relationship originated, but I recall there being somewhat conflicting memories among the Annuated. But I'm pretty sure they all point to a biological symbiosis of some sort.

Captrek July 6 2009 03:58 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Quote:

Kestrel wrote: (Post 3157594)
In short, even mature and democratic societies don't stop people being greedy and thinking they deserve symbionts. Verad wouldn't be the only one willing to kill for the social and mental advantage of Joining.

Presumably, having a stolen symbiont would be neither socially nor legally acceptable. It would be a difficult thing to hide, especially if you wanted to enjoy most of the advantages of having the symbiont, and anybody who stole a symbiont and was caught would have the symbiont extracted, resulting in the death of the host who stole it. Unless youíre planning on going into hiding in the Gamma Quadrant, I donít see any point in stealing the slug.

On that subject, I kind of wonder what Verad Dax was planning on doing after leaving DS9. Going into hiding in the Gamma Quadrant might make sense for Verad, but itís horrible for Dax. If Verad dies in the Gamma Quadrant, Dax dies too, for lack of another available host. What happens when the interests of the host and the symbiont are so much at odds? How does the combined being make the decision?

happydave July 6 2009 04:39 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
From memory don't they grow in the pools on Trill in the caves?

Looking at Memory Alpha, it seems this way.

http://memory-alpha.org/en/wiki/Caves_of_Mak%27ala

Captrek July 6 2009 05:22 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Quote:

happydave wrote: (Post 3157761)
From memory don't they grow in the pools on Trill in the caves?

Yes, there is a scene in Equilibrium in which we see unjoined symbionts in a pool being cared for people called “Guardians.” In this unjoined state, they are conscious, and swim around and communicate with each other through some kind of electrical signals that are visible like lightning.

What the episode does not explain is where those symbionts came from, and I mean that on both the individual and species level. Where does an individual symbiont come from? Are there a mother symbiont and father symbiont that somehow mate and give birth to it? And what about the species? Did it evolve naturally, or was it created?

Timo July 6 2009 09:48 PM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
As said, no onscreen evidence. Thus, enter my interpretation:

A long time ago in caves of planet Trill, slimy creatures roamed the dark subterranean waterways and used electric pulses both to stun their prey, and to communicate with their own kind. A bit shorter a time ago, they had gotten very good at both stunning and communicating - and had begun, more or less accidentally at first, to communicate with their victims rather than just with their own kind. They eventually learned how to use the pulses for luring their prey in - and, later, for controlling their prey. In essence, they could "possess" more advanced creatures. Eventually, this path of evolution allowed them to refine the possession into complete bodily control, and now they were free to leave their fetid underground pools and start preying on creatures of the dry land...

Perhaps their victims included primitive apes, which then evolved into humanlike creatures - while the Trills evolved apace, constantly capturing a small portion of the ape-human population, and eventually becoming a biological fixture of the ape-human culture. They did little harm to their human hosts, as they were more valuable when used as hunting bodies than when used as food.

Or perhaps there were no apes on planet Trill originally, but the Trills were able to hone their possession skills on other species, so that when the first spacefaring humanoids arrived on the planet, they fell prey to these master hunters.

Either way, the Trills would now be in control, at least in control of small population groups. And now they would launch into a propaganda war: the population they controlled would start spreading the gospel that said the Trills were friendly and indeed beneficial, and that everybody should try one.

Eventually, this would indeed catch on, as the Trill promises were not completely empty ones. The ability to carry memories from generation to generation would exist for real. The story about the possession being "benevolent" would mostly be fabrication, though; most hosts would be under strict control, and strictly controlled to tell everybody that they were free.

All sorts of hosts would be compatible with the Trill, but they would soon develop a preference towards certain "easy" species. The spotted species typically associated with the Trills would be a favorite, for having that nice pouch on the tummy and thus requiring little in the way of surgery or violent burrowing... Regulation of the "market" would be important, though, and so all sorts of propaganda would emerge on this "compatibility issue".

The Trills would still breed the old-fashioned way, in the pools. But otherwise, they'd abandon most of their original ways, and would take nourishment not through hunting, but through very modest tapping of the gastrointestinal system of the host. They'd also become quite intelligent and civilized - and whatever they lacked in education, they could coerce out of their hosts' educations.

Timo Saloniemi

SharkD July 7 2009 03:38 AM

Re: Where do Trill symbionts come from?
 
Quote:

captrek wrote: (Post 3157407)
On a related note, why would it be so devastating to Trill society if it became known that they have a lot more hosts physically capable of hosting symbionts than they have symbionts?

Every culture has its elements of angst I guess. The way they handled it in the show wasn't that great, though. Not one of my favorite episodes.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.