The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Deep Space Nine (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=40)
-   -   Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses. (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=85964)

Aquehonga March 18 2009 10:47 PM

Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
Scott Bakula as Commander/Captain Benjamin L. Sisko

Brian Bonsall as Jake Sisko*

Jolene Blaylock as Major Kira Nerys

Linda Park as Lt. Com Jadzia Dax

John Billingsley as Odo

Dominic Keating as Dr. Bashir

Connor Trineer as Chief Miles O'Brien

Anthony Montgomery as Quark

Dean Spockwell as Admiral Ross (later seasons)

In tribute to Quantum Leap, when Admiral Ross comes in during The War, his nickname is "Al". Sometimes folks call Ross "Big Al" for his take-no-prisoners, no horse hockey mentality.

Bakula's Sisko served as Spockwell's Admiral Ross's 1st Officer fighting the Tzenkethi. Sisko's nicknames back then were "Sam", most of the time, & "Sammo Fun" on the battlefield.

Admiral Ross calls Ben "Sam" to most folks' confusion. Admiral Ross & Sisko often speak fondly of a mutual friend back in San Francisco whose a master statistician for Starfleet Command (nick)named Ziggy. Ziggy sends Ross mission probability projections which he shares with Sisko.

Ziggy's voice is provided by Deborah Pratt.

What would this DS9 had been like?

All opinions/views welcome.

*I know! He wasn't on ENT was he:confused:

Photon March 18 2009 11:04 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
Quote:

Aquehonga wrote: (Post 2727619)
Scott Bakula as Commander/Captain Benjamin L. Sisko

Brian Bonsall as Jake Sisko

Jolene Blaylock as Major Kira Nerys

Linda Park as Lt. Com Jadzia Dax

John Billingsley as Odo

Dominic Keating as Dr. Bashir

Connor Trineer as Chief Miles O'Brien

Anthony Montgomery as Quark

Dean Spockwell as Admiral Ross (later seasons)

In tribute to Quantum Leap, when Admiral Ross comes in during The War, his nickname is "Al". Sometimes folks call Ross "Big Al" for his take-no-prisoners, no horse hockey mentality.

Bakula's Sisko served as Spockwell's Admiral Ross's 1st Officer fighting the Tzenkethi. Sisko's nicknames back then were "Sam", most of the time, & "Sammo Fun" on the battlefield.

Admiral Ross calls Ben "Sam" to most folks' confusion. Admiral Ross & Sisko often speak fondly of a mutual friend back in San Francisco whose a master statistician for Starfleet Command (nick)named Ziggy. Ziggy sends Ross mission probability projections which he shares with Sisko.

Ziggy's voice is provided by Deborah Pratt.


What would this DS9 had been like?

All opinions/views welcome.

Bacula would have to work on his tan.

Its interesting, though I doubt DS9 purist could stomach it.

I'm quite sure some of the originals would like to come and do Trek work

Thor Damar March 19 2009 12:49 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
As a 'DS9 purist' I would have to say no to all of the above with the exception of Dean Stockwell as admiral Ross( or Fed president?). ;)

Jono March 19 2009 01:13 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
The casting I most dislike would be Montgomery as Quark. I don't think he could pull it off, too young really. I'd shift Billingsley to Quark, Keating to Odo and Mont to Bashir. Mont as Bashir is a much better fit, a young officer full of life and youthful exuberance. Billingsley has a better force for Quark and seems more likely to handle the role. Keating has that grumpy manner and voice that would match Quark.

Additionally I find the Quantum Leap stuff to be pointless. Early on the series I wouldn't care about a little wink to the show but the constant references to a show that has nothing to do with Trek just make me want to rolleyes.

USS Triumphant March 19 2009 06:33 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
The only character I might retroactively recast with an Enterprise actor is Jadzia - recast with Blalock. The rest of the DS9 cast was pretty much perfect the way they were.

JustKate March 19 2009 06:39 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
I am not enamoured of the idea - the cast of Enterprise was pretty good on the whole, but the cast of DS9 was so excellent - but I particularly dislike swapping out Avery Brooks for Scott Bakula. Not a fan of the actor, and I thought his Archer the blandest of all our captains. "Bland" is not what DS9 needed.

Kira Nerys March 19 2009 08:29 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
Ds9 is fine the way it is .

TS-1838-SWATH March 19 2009 09:03 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
Quote:

JustKate wrote: (Post 2730735)
I am not enamoured of the idea
The cast of DS9 was so excellent - but I particularly dislike swapping out Avery Brooks for Scott Bakula. I thought his Archer the blandest of all our captains. "Bland" is not what DS9 needed.

AGREED

However Scott Bakula was not given much to work with --> Archer
Fan of his QL work

D Man March 19 2009 09:50 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
Quote:

Aquehonga wrote: (Post 2727619)
Scott Bakula as Commander/Captain Benjamin L. Sisko

Brian Bonsall as Jake Sisko*

Jolene Blaylock as Major Kira Nerys

Linda Park as Lt. Com Jadzia Dax

John Billingsley as Odo

Dominic Keating as Dr. Bashir

Connor Trineer as Chief Miles O'Brien

Anthony Montgomery as Quark

Dean Spockwell as Admiral Ross (later seasons)

Interesting list...I think Trineer as O'Brien and Billingsley as Odo would work the best, since they seemed to be the most capable and versatile actors from Enterprise. Bakula as Sisko would be interesting, but I don't think he has the intense "presence" that Avery Brooks conveyed, especially during emotional moments like in "Rapture" or "Far Beyond The Stars."

I'm also wondering why you keep spelling Dean Stockwell's name wrong like you always do in the BSG forum...are you gunning for a Trek connection with "Spockwell?" ;)

Saito S March 19 2009 10:49 PM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
Eh... I couldn't see it. I can't deny that I am a "DS9 purist", though. :D

I will say that - although I didn't like Enterprise at all - the actors were not really among the reasons for that. I think that they were pretty good, on the whole. But I can't really see anyone in any of the DS9 roles except those who were already in those roles, cause IMO DS9 had no weak links, acting-wise.

Scott Bakula as Archer... he's the reason I said "on the whole" when saying that Enterprise had good acting. He is not a bad actor. In fact, he's pretty good. But in my opinion, he was a terrible choice for a Starfleet captain. He does not have at all the right presence for that role. It's the same as how I felt about George Clooney as Batman in Batman and Robin. Clooney is a fantastic actor. But he made a positively awful Batman. It just didn't mesh well, him in that costume, with those lines... Granted, that was a laughably bad movie in just about every way, so maybe that's not a great example. But you get the idea. :p

Red Ranger March 20 2009 05:25 AM

Re: Recast of DS9 with ENTERPRISE's actors & actresses.
 
I really can't see any of those actors in those roles, except maybe John Billngsley as Quark. I always though Tony Todd as Sisko would be good. He has a commanding voice and he was great in The Visitor. I could also see Jeffrey Combs as Dukat, too, even though he's a tad short. -- RR


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:34 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.