The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Battlestar Galactica & Caprica (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=29)
-   -   Earth (spoilers through 4x17) (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=84433)

Lrning2fly07 March 4 2009 12:59 AM

Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
So are we going to hear anymore about Earth? I would be really disappointed if, by the end of the show, they don't connect the Earth in the story to Earth in reality. It would make sense if this is the far future, and all they have to say is something about how humans first came from Earth, before going to Kobol.

I would be disappointed if they just ignore this point. Their Earth has a North American continent, why does it have to look so similar to our Earth if this is a Star Wars-like reality, where there is no connection to the real world at all?

Brent March 4 2009 01:30 AM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Two trains of thought on this right now:

1.) The "Earth" we saw wasn't our Earth, and they will discover a planet, and call it Earth, and that will be our Earth

2.) The "Earth' we saw was our planet, and we are thousands of years in the future

BTW, humans did not come from Earth. Everyone came from Kobol, the 13th tribe was a tribe of Cylons the Kobol people made, they settled the "Earth" we saw, the other 12 races were Humas and settled the 12 colonies.

Verteron March 4 2009 01:43 AM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
BTW, humans did not come from Earth. Everyone came from Kobol, the 13th tribe was a tribe of Cylons the Kobol people made, they settled the "Earth" we saw, the other 12 races were Humas and settled the 12 colonies.

I said this before, and I stand by it: the whole repeating history thing doesn't preclude there being a pre-Kobol iteration that started on our Earth, in our future.

One other 'fringe' possibility I pondered is if it's actually set in the distant past, and the whole dinosaur/fossil thing is either a Cylon trick (or will be totally ignored) or that they'll end up 'seeding' Earth with the building blocks for human-Cylon hybrid life to eventually 'evolve' back to a familiar human shape, but I don't think that's going to be the case. It's a bit too Star Trekkie for today's Ron Moore!

darkwing_duck1 March 4 2009 01:46 AM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Hasn't Moore (or someone on staff) already said in a podcast or interview that the planet shown IS our Earth, albeit in an undisclosed timeframe?

Harvey March 4 2009 01:51 AM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Moore has stated that the planet is EARTH, but I don't think he's used the words "OUR Earth." I suspect that it is as you say, however.

Mr. Laser Beam March 4 2009 02:10 AM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
humans did not come from Earth. Everyone came from Kobol

That has not been firmly established.

Starwind March 4 2009 05:58 AM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
There's still the problem of the 12 Colonies original flags. Why in the galaxy would they only have star patterns visible from EARTH? (The same patterns that confirmed they had reached Earth) It's been implied the 12 never went TO Earth, so what gives, if they were never ever there? You don't put a star pattern on your Flag if it has no significance to you.

Green Shirt March 4 2009 08:07 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Lrning2fly07 wrote: (Post 2673651)
So are we going to hear anymore about Earth?

Since they removed the word "Earth" from the opening sequence and left it as simply "a home" we may have heard the last on the subject. Unless that's just misdirection.

bigdaddy March 4 2009 08:51 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Yes the Earth they found was the one and only Earth they were looking for and was talked about, but I think there are several Earths. The series finale is called Daybreak so I think it's safe to saw they find a planet and fight John for it. That planet will become our Earth.

Chris3123 March 4 2009 08:59 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
Two trains of thought on this right now:

1.) The "Earth" we saw wasn't our Earth, and they will discover a planet, and call it Earth, and that will be our Earth

2.) The "Earth' we saw was our planet, and we are thousands of years in the future

Except you are forgetting that when they first showed "Earth", we saw the landmasses, and they were exactly as they are on our Earth. You could easily make out North America, for example. So it has to be 2.

Awesome Possum March 4 2009 11:21 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Chris3123 wrote: (Post 2676430)
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
Two trains of thought on this right now:

1.) The "Earth" we saw wasn't our Earth, and they will discover a planet, and call it Earth, and that will be our Earth

2.) The "Earth' we saw was our planet, and we are thousands of years in the future

Except you are forgetting that when they first showed "Earth", we saw the landmasses, and they were exactly as they are on our Earth. You could easily make out North America, for example. So it has to be 2.

The Earth we saw at the end of season three was clearly our Earth. There were no landmasses seen on the Earth they landed on that looked like they do on our Earth. Although given that they didn't bother to show it, we may never know.

Or the planet they do find, if they find one, may happen to look exactly like our Earth.

Chris3123 March 5 2009 10:51 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Awesome Possum wrote: (Post 2677005)
Quote:

Chris3123 wrote: (Post 2676430)
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
Two trains of thought on this right now:

1.) The "Earth" we saw wasn't our Earth, and they will discover a planet, and call it Earth, and that will be our Earth

2.) The "Earth' we saw was our planet, and we are thousands of years in the future

Except you are forgetting that when they first showed "Earth", we saw the landmasses, and they were exactly as they are on our Earth. You could easily make out North America, for example. So it has to be 2.

The Earth we saw at the end of season three was clearly our Earth. There were no landmasses seen on the Earth they landed on that looked like they do on our Earth. Although given that they didn't bother to show it, we may never know.

Or the planet they do find, if they find one, may happen to look exactly like our Earth.

I assumed the Earth they found actually was the Earth they showed at the end of S3. Why wouldn't it be?

Green Shirt March 6 2009 03:12 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Awesome Possum wrote: (Post 2677005)
Quote:

Chris3123 wrote: (Post 2676430)
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
Two trains of thought on this right now:

1.) The "Earth" we saw wasn't our Earth, and they will discover a planet, and call it Earth, and that will be our Earth

2.) The "Earth' we saw was our planet, and we are thousands of years in the future

Except you are forgetting that when they first showed "Earth", we saw the landmasses, and they were exactly as they are on our Earth. You could easily make out North America, for example. So it has to be 2.

The Earth we saw at the end of season three was clearly our Earth. There were no landmasses seen on the Earth they landed on that looked like they do on our Earth. Although given that they didn't bother to show it, we may never know.

Or the planet they do find, if they find one, may happen to look exactly like our Earth.

Yeah, Miri's planet -but with clouds. ;)

Chess Piece Face March 6 2009 03:46 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Maybe the earth they pulled out to at the end of season 3 was our earth, which they will get to, but the earth they landed on wasn't.

Or, maybe it was and they will go back there and use cylon tech to go to sleep and resurrect themselves in the future after the radiation clears or something.

Cartoonist March 6 2009 04:11 PM

Re: Earth (spoilers through 4x17)
 
Quote:

Babaganoosh wrote: (Post 2673871)
Quote:

Brent wrote: (Post 2673755)
humans did not come from Earth. Everyone came from Kobol

That has not been firmly established.

I have a really hard time believing everyone came from Kobol rather than Earth. Not with all the anthropological record we have of man evolving on Earth. It just wouldn't make any sense to me if they were to say man came from Kobol and for some reason lost or abandoned his technology. How would that explain the neanderthals and the many stages of man? How would it explain the little similarities like the neckties and suits?

It makes far more sense to me to think that thousands of years from now, humans HAVE to leave earth for some reason. Maybe we've ruined it with pollution, or climate change has made it uninhabitable, and survivors flee the planet in generational ships. They're in transit at sub-light speeds for hundreds or thousands of years. They colonize Kobol. Then, thousands of years later, for some reason, they have to leave Kobol. Most go to the closer twelve colonies planets, either no longer believing earth exists or not believing humans could survive on the earth they'd left. Maybe they created an entire race of skinjob cylons thinking the cylons could withstand whatever damage had been done to earth and make it fit for humans again. The cylons make the longer voyage back home to the abandoned Earth, a voyage that takes thousands of years. But by then, earth's just a myth to the twelve colonies.

That makes more sense to me than thinking we all came from Kobol, lost our technology, reverted to apes, evolved again, and after hundreds of thousands of years, we've reinvented the gods of Olympus and accidentally recreated the necktie.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:05 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.