The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Would a Babylon 5 animated series work? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=84074)

Aquehonga February 27 2009 05:38 PM

Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
And I mean a series aimed at & for adults. Young folks & teens would be free to watch if they wanted to. In fact they should.

I watched ST, the TZ & like shows/films since I was in the 1st & 2nd grade. Had B5 existed way back then I would've watched that too. And even at those young ages I knew, got what was going on, at least most of it.

Kids are no different now. So, cartoon or not, the youngins & teens should watch an animated B5 series if they want to.

The youngins/teens "tangent" aside, I'll get to the main point(s?).

*If JMS were to make a B5 animated series, he should hire the highest quality writers around, assuming JMS himself wouldn't be the primary writer for suggested series.

*Should such a series be a telenovel like the original B5? Or should it be self-contained tales for the most part? Or be a Babylon Five-rse anthology? Should it be in a ST style involving ships exploring? Or be B5 centered? Or both? Such a series could be a combination of all the things suggested so far, allowing episodes exploring various aspects & history of the B5-rse. Other options?

*Should the show be on a network,syndicated or on a subscription cable/satellite channel (HBO,SHOW)? How many episodes should there be per season? How long should the episodes be? Should there be 90-minute B5 animated films as part or in addition to a half-hour or hour show?

*Who would the actors/actresses be supplying the voices? Who should they be? IE(suggestions):Original B5 castmembers obviously. But Mark Hamill, Frank Welker, Nichelle Nichols, Leonard Nimoy, Kate Mulgrew etc would be great to have also.

*The type of animation is very important also. It goes without saying the folks who make Transformers:Animated would NOT be allowed to make this show, or be allowed anywhere near it, EVER!

No one, in their right mind(s), want(s) to see Sinclair, Sheridan, Londo, Ivanova, Garibaldi, etc with chins HUGE, loooong & DEEP enough to fill the Grand Canyon.:wtf:

Wtf is up with that Jay Leno chin crap on TF:A? NONE of that puh-leez!?!?

*.....................?

YOUR thoughts>

Professor Zoom February 27 2009 06:31 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
I think sometimes...we should let stories just be self contained. B5's story was told. Sure, the Universe is ripe for more stories, but I would rather be left wanting more than seeing stories that are wanting...

Forbin February 27 2009 06:38 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Have y'all ever seen Babylon Park?

OMG! They killed Koshi!!

Harvey February 27 2009 06:44 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
After all the attempted spin-offs and side stories written besides the five year arc, I'd vote no on this. It either wouldn't last or wouldn't be very good. Either way, we'd end up being disappointed. It's best to let Babylon 5 lie dormant for a while.

Pingfaaaaarrrrgh February 27 2009 06:57 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
No, it would only be a case of "well we can't make another series so lets make a cartoon instead".

B5 is done, it was great, leave it at that.

Aquehonga February 27 2009 08:00 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Quote:

Forbin wrote: (Post 2659970)
Have y'all ever seen Babylon Park?

OMG! They killed Koshi!!

:lol:

Good one:techman:

:guffaw:

Cutter John February 27 2009 09:13 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
I'd watch it in a second. But like the others have said, I think the B5 story has pretty much been told. Time to let it rest.

Tulin February 27 2009 09:35 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Why the need to hire Kate Mulgrew?

Have you not seen Claudia's impression?!?

PKTrekGirl February 27 2009 10:38 PM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
I'd watch it and buy it on DVD. But I'm not sure how good it would be. Especially given the budget constraints it would likely have.

JMS was able to put together a couple of low-budget but reasonably decent 'episodes' with The Lost Tales.

If they were gonna tell anymore B5 stories, I'd prefer them in that format. Not as cartoons.

I think the B5 universe is too complex for cartoons anyway.

Ryan Thomas Riddle February 28 2009 12:28 AM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Animated? Well, I suppose as a spin-off of some of the stories we never got much of in the series.

Sheridan and the Rangers

Lyta and The Vorlon
The Adventures of G'Kar and the Teep
The New Adventures of G'Kar (featuring Dr. Franklin)
The Prophetic Adventures of Valen and Zathris
The Grim Adventures of Londo Mollari and the Keeper

Mr. Garabaldi's Missing Hair

The possibilities are endless.

Mr Light February 28 2009 01:18 AM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Hey hey, a Valen animated series could be pretty cool. That's one chapter of the series completely unexplored that could have a ton of action... against the Shadows!

Ryan Thomas Riddle February 28 2009 02:54 AM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Quote:

Mr Light wrote: (Post 2661189)
Hey hey, a Valen animated series could be pretty cool. That's one chapter of the series completely unexplored that could have a ton of action... against the Shadows!

I certainly would like to see Valen's story beyond the three-part comic book series -- perhaps a novel.

Pilot Ace February 28 2009 03:09 AM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Quote:

PKTrekGirl wrote: (Post 2660719)
I think the B5 universe is too complex for cartoons anyway.

Oy, that's a can of worms.

RandyS February 28 2009 03:46 AM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Quote:

Professor Zoom wrote: (Post 2659949)
I think sometimes...we should let stories just be self contained. B5's story was told. Sure, the Universe is ripe for more stories, but I would rather be left wanting more than seeing stories that are wanting...

I agree in this case. The Lost Tales left me feeling exactly that way.

Plain Simple February 28 2009 08:59 AM

Re: Would a Babylon 5 animated series work?
 
Good stories can work in any medium, so why not cartoons. Although the quality of all the B5 stand alone projects doesn't particularly make me want more. If they could do a longer story arc fleshing out one of the stories that were referenced to in the series but never told (not on the tv screen anyway, I know some of it was told in the books, but I never read any of those and I assume nor have most people who saw B5 on tv), like the story of Londo and the keeper, or the telepath war, the resolution of the drakh plague, stuff like that.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.