The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   General Trek Discussion (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   Which was the best homage to TOS (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=81323)

Gotham Central January 31 2009 07:20 PM

Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Each of the spinoff Trek series did some kind of tribute to TOS. Which was the best/most memorable?

James Bond January 31 2009 07:34 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
DS9: Trials and Tribble-ations, without a doubt.

BillJ January 31 2009 07:56 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Trials and Tribble-ations
In A Mirror, Darkly
Relics


While the first three are entertaining... Flashback is just a huge turd.

captcalhoun January 31 2009 08:12 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Trials and Tribble-ations, no contest.

IaMD is second, but I'd say there's a margin between them.

Relics is third by a larger margin.

Flashback was complete pony.

Okay, Relics had Scotty in the story, (which was cool) and recreated the bridge of the 1701 (which was also cool), but IaMD went further in its recreations of TOS (FOOD CUBES!) but T&T wins for the fact that they went back into an old episode. that's just too cool for school.

Flashback was dreck because while they had a hallucinatory trip back in time, a) it was a f*#%ing HALLUCINATION! and b) they got stuff wrong like killing of Valtane despite the fact that he's quite bloody clearly alive at the end of TUC on the sodding bridge of the Excelsior! oh, and c) it was the Movie Era, not TOS.

The Grim Ghost January 31 2009 08:47 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Definitely not Flashback considering that Janeway went out of her way to criticize the way things were done during that time, despite the fact that she did similar things time and time again :rolleyes:

Piper January 31 2009 09:35 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Trials for me too, although Relics isn't THAT far behind it.

AdmiralGarak January 31 2009 09:43 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Trials, because it was completely brilliant both as a tribute to TOS and as a DS9 romp.

mirandafave January 31 2009 09:50 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
T&T because it alluded to the mystery of the Klingon foreheads, it put DS9 crew into TOS uniforms and it fitted into just such an iconic episode made all the more iconic by their visit.

Hated Relics because in my opinion they just sent Mr Scotty off like a doddery old man. Liked that they brought Scotty into the TNG timeframe so he could work his miracles again but they managed to fumble his character.

Flashback was cool in that we got to catch a glimpse of the Exclesior and see Sulu as Captain but all of the above criticisms of it are just too true.

In a Mirror Darkly was a great tip of the hat but more so to the MU - although they did go the whole hog and change even the show opening credits for the episode. That in itself is an homage.

jamestyler February 1 2009 02:58 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Trials. For all that could be said to praise it... it was just fun.

IAMD was my Enterprise highlight. Partly because of the geek moments in it, partly because of Hoshi. But that was more fun to watch than Relics which, while I did enjoy it, the others had more entertainment value while revisiting things instead of saying goodbye to them.

Flashback... that was just bad.

Stardate February 1 2009 03:01 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
DS9: Trials and Tribble-ations the best DS9 episode ever.

sbk1234 February 1 2009 03:10 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Like most everyone else, T&T. But I have to give special mention for Relics. The holodeck scene was, IMHO, poignant and brilliant. There was a sense of loss that I feel really hit home.

Gotham Central February 1 2009 04:10 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
I think that it is a testament to the writers and production staff on DS9 that they managed to produce the most memorable anniversary episode. It was the folks working on Voyager that initially decided to do an anniversary episode. The folks working on DS9 were not even sure that they wanted to do one. Yet after brainstorming the concept, they came up with one of the most memorable episodes of modern trek. T&T also has the distinction of being the only modern Trek episode included on the DVD sets with the original series.

You can definately tell from the backstage interviews that the cast and crew had a blast making the episode and it shows on screen.

WHF February 1 2009 04:50 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
I think the best tribute to Star Trek was done on Futurama: Where No Fan Has Gone Before. You could really tell how much the writers loved TOS.

From this list I have to go with the majority and say DS9 did it the best.

jamestyler February 1 2009 07:33 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Quote:

Gotham Central wrote: (Post 2564021)
You can definately tell from the backstage interviews that the cast and crew had a blast making the episode and it shows on screen.

I was quite surprised at that, especially Terry Farrell. Maybe it was just not seeing/reading many interviews with her before, but I didn't expect her to be that enthusiastic.

I'm also really glad they ditched the second idea of the Star Trek fan planet. It might have been fun - but not as fun as having DS9 and TOS merge together like that.

Even a girl I'm dating who hates Star Trek watched it and loved it. Her thoughts were "Thats so weird... and awesome."

QuasarVM February 1 2009 07:35 PM

Re: Which was the best homage to TOS
 
Tough choice between TandT and IaMD...

But, in the end, I had to pick IaMD...the brightest spot of the only watchable season of Enterprise.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.