The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   General Trek Discussion (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”. (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=80104)

Aquehonga January 19 2009 09:56 PM

Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Spock's mother's full {maiden} name is Amanda Grayson. Robin's real name is Dick Grayson.

That's circumstantial proof 1. Or is it “proof”?

Circumstantial proof 2 to possibly back this up is a reference in a TNG episode to the baseball club Gotham Dynamites.

As in Gotham City?

Is this “proof” as well?

Then there's the tangent issue here of Spock possibly, if not probably, definitely{?}, being a descendant of Arthur Conan Doyle. He is, isn't he? Based on STVI:TUC.

If I'm right then both Spock & Robin {Dick Grayson} are descendants of Arthur Conan Doyle.

How cool is that?

JoeZhang January 19 2009 10:11 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

Aquehonga wrote: (Post 2519428)
Spock's mother's full {maiden} name is Amanda Grayson. Robin's real name is Dick Grayson.

That's circumstantial proof 1. Or is it “proof”?

Circumstantial proof 2 to possibly back this up is a reference in a TNG episode to the baseball club Gotham Dynamites.

As in Gotham City?

Is this “proof” as well?

Then there's the tangent issue here of Spock possibly, if not probably, definitely{?}, being a descendant of Arthur Conan Doyle. He is, isn't he? Based on STVI:TUC.

If I'm right then both Spock & Robin {Dick Grayson} are descendants of Arthur Conan Doyle.

How cool is that?

The Gotham baseball team (in the comics at least) are known as the Gotham Knights.

captcalhoun January 19 2009 10:22 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
yes and the Gotham team named on 'Buck' Bokai's baseball card was the Gotham Bats.

and i think it's a coinky-dink. or are you going to tell me I'm related to Stephen Fry because we share the same surname and Bones is a descendent of Beast from X-Men because they are both Doctor McCoy?

RandyS January 19 2009 10:32 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Nope. Amanda's great-great-great grandfather was Benjamin Spock.

Ryan Thomas Riddle January 19 2009 10:40 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
According to Enterprise, Superman comics exist in the Trekverse. Therefore it goes to reason that so do Batman comics and that Dick Grayson is a fictional character within that universe.

blaXXer January 19 2009 10:49 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

Aquehonga wrote: (Post 2519428)
Spock's mother's full {maiden} name is Amanda Grayson. Robin's real name is Dick Grayson.

That's circumstantial proof 1. Or is it “proof”?

Circumstantial proof 2 to possibly back this up is a reference in a TNG episode to the baseball club Gotham Dynamites.

As in Gotham City?

Is this “proof” as well?

Then there's the tangent issue here of Spock possibly, if not probably, definitely{?}, being a descendant of Arthur Conan Doyle. He is, isn't he? Based on STVI:TUC.

If I'm right then both Spock & Robin {Dick Grayson} are descendants of Arthur Conan Doyle.

How cool is that?

You're an idiot, proof, or is that "proof"?:devil:

Crypto January 19 2009 11:18 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

blaXXer wrote: (Post 2519570)
You're an idiot, proof, or is that "proof"?:devil:

C'mon - you know better than that. Dial it back, please.

Besides, after the travesty that was X-Men/Star Trek, is this really so different? :vulcan:

john titor January 19 2009 11:59 PM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

middyseafort wrote: (Post 2519548)
According to Enterprise, Superman comics exist in the Trekverse. Therefore it goes to reason that so do Batman comics and that Dick Grayson is a fictional character within that universe.

not to be anal but there's no physical evidence that batman comics exist in the st universe.

USS Triumphant January 20 2009 12:04 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

john titor wrote: (Post 2519796)
not to be anal but there's no physical evidence that batman comics exist in the st universe.

And you'd know, being from the future and all, right? ;)

EnsignRicky January 20 2009 12:36 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

USS_Triumphant wrote: (Post 2519810)
Quote:

john titor wrote: (Post 2519796)
not to be anal but there's no physical evidence that batman comics exist in the st universe.

And you'd know, being from the future and all, right? ;)

You don't have to be from the future, you just have to know that Batman has never been mentioned in any incarnation of Star Trek. That being said, if Superman is shown to exist, it only seems natural for Batman to follow. Jeez, look what I'm typing about; Thank God for anonymity.

Aquehonga January 20 2009 01:33 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

middyseafort wrote: (Post 2519548)
According to Enterprise, Superman comics exist in the Trekverse. Therefore it goes to reason that so do Batman comics and that Dick Grayson is a fictional character within that universe.


Re: this news^>

As the tree said to the lumberjack: “I'm stumped!”:confused:

USS Triumphant January 20 2009 01:37 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

EnsignRicky wrote: (Post 2519906)
You don't have to be from the future, you just have to know that Batman has never been mentioned in any incarnation of Star Trek. That being said, if Superman is shown to exist, it only seems natural for Batman to follow. Jeez, look what I'm typing about; Thank God for anonymity.

:lol:

But I was actually referring to his username. Visit www.johntitor.com and you'll see what I meant.

Semah January 20 2009 02:35 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Quote:

Misfit Toy wrote: (Post 2519676)
Quote:

blaXXer wrote: (Post 2519570)
You're an idiot, proof, or is that "proof"?:devil:

C'mon - you know better than that. Dial it back, please.

Besides, after the travesty that was X-Men/Star Trek, is this really so different? :vulcan:


Damn it! I had forgotten about those. Now I have to drink until I forget again!

Aquehonga January 20 2009 02:59 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Based on what folks are saying its more likely Spock's descended from Robin Williams than Robin of BATMAN.

I hope not!

Spock's ancestor being the Sultan of Schmaltz:mad: The Magistrate of Mr. Goodbars:scream:

IF Mr. Spock turns out to be Robin William's descendant, I'll lose at least 80% of my admiration & respect for him.

Probability now pointing toward that Robin {His Irritance} more likely being Spock's ancestor than Batman's Robin:mad:

Figures as much. How's that for a kick in the teeth?

Oh, the pain, as Dr. Smith would say.

Robin Willliams indeed:scream::mad:

Mr. Williams can Robin this>

:brickwall:

T'Cal January 20 2009 03:46 AM

Re: Is Spock a descendant of Robin from BATMAN? I have “evidence”.
 
Related to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle? I always thought he was refering to Sir ACD's character, Sherlock Holmes.

***SPOILER ALERT***
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>




They both fictional...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.