The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Voyager (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=41)
-   -   Kes V Seven of Nine (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=79803)

Clym January 16 2009 01:48 PM

Kes V Seven of Nine
 
which character do you think was better and added more to the series as a whole?

Evil_Kirkneivel January 16 2009 03:04 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
That's a tough question for me to answer. Each was so different than the other. Kes was very appealing to me, with her pixie haircut, sensual voice, and intelligence. Seven of Nine was the opposite - in your face lil Abner body in a catsuit to appeal to young (and old) fanboys. Kes was under-used; Seven over-used. They could have easily existed together on the show, since their characters and stories had little in common.

Seven will always be associated with why Voyager went wrong, but I thought some of her eps were okay. The problem was that the writing became cliched (the writers were, at that time, soap opera television writers, and it showed). Neither character would have been served well in the later years of Voyager, so it's good that Kes left.

Nick Ryder January 16 2009 03:14 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Kes was okay, felt too much like a Deanna Troi-esque character, although that lame '8 year lifespan' thing really sucked, so what? If she lasted to the end and didn't evolve, she would have gotten really old and died by the time they got 'home'.

Seven was okay, she grew on me toward the end, since really around that time the Doctor got over his 'Data- finding my humanity' arc, so they needed that 'alien' foil. I always wished they would have just brought like Troi onto the show permanently, or somehow have her brought to Voyager. Kes was okay, but Jen Lein at the time wasn't, so it was good that she went when she did. But its still sad that she had to go.

Loupjo January 16 2009 03:27 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Seven of Nine was by far the more interesting character of the two. She had a lot of potential and was involved in interesting story lines. However she was also used in lots of not so interesting stories and the character was overused. I also didn't really like the way her character developped at all.
Kes was less interesting but I still voted for her as she never got on my nerves the way Seven did.

billcosby January 16 2009 03:43 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Seven.
I can think of two beautifully big reasons.

exodus January 16 2009 04:21 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Seven of Nine, hands down.

Not only was Seven a better thought out character but Jeri Ryan acted rings around anything Jen Lien brought to the table. Ryan put more emotion into just a simple expression than Lien did in 3 years.

kimc January 16 2009 05:19 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Quote:

Evil_Kirkneivel wrote: (Post 2508506)
Seven will always be associated with why Voyager went wrong, but I thought some of her eps were okay.

That's my take on it too but then I have a soft spot for the earlier seasons.

exodus January 16 2009 05:35 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
I don't know, If Seven can be associated with why Voyager went wrong then what was the reason before that to cause them to replace one character with another?

Voyager was going downhill way before Seven.

One character isn't to blame for Voyager's decline, Trek spin-off's had simply run it's course. Trek fans were even getting bored of Trek.

Obi Wana Jones January 16 2009 07:18 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
7 of 9 was just plain hot :techman:

Early Kes did nothing for me; late Kes with long curly hair
peaked my "intellectual" curiosity. :drool:

I agree with Nick's evaluations of the characters:

Kes = Troi; early Kes with short hair/no personality = early Troi, with studip beehive hairdo and really badly cut uniforms.

7 of 9 = Data "Pinocchio: I want to be a real boy" but with nice ta-tas

7 of 9 was a much more interesting character.

Johnhead99 January 16 2009 09:05 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
I love me some Kes. Her backstory in Pathways is some of the best reading from that era. It was about 40 minutes of pure pleasure for me.
I like 7 but Kes is where it is at. Hot.

Lynx January 16 2009 09:13 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Kes was a better Star Trek character. She actually personified the spirit of Star Trek with her will to learn and explore. Her mental abilities and her personality made her unique. She wasn't the typical "action-character" like Janeway, Torres and Seven, more a contrast and a complement to them, something that made her very interesting as a character.

Kes was beautiful, nice, helpful and friendly but also strong-willed, determined, brave and curious. She had a way to get her will without using force or threats. This can be seen in several episodes, like "Resolutions" where she persuaded Tuvok to go back after Janeway and Chakotay, something Kim got almost court-martialed for when he tried.

Kes's only flaw was the ridiculous lifespan. However, there were hints in some episodes that her lifespan could be prolonged which I think would have happened if she had remained in the show.

Seven was the kind of character that we have seen in so many movies and series, the typical good-looking and sexy female hero, however she had an interesting background story and her struggle to overcome the years she was a Borg and trying to be human again was remarcable.

I agree that Seven was over-used and Kes under-used. But I also think that there would have been room for both of them in the series, it would actually have been interesting to see the inter-action between them.

As for the actresses, both did a terrific job and really gave life to the characters. I must give Jennifer Lien special credit here, considering the fact that she was more inexperienced than Ryan but still did a terrific job. Both actresses deserves best possible credits for their efforts.

teya January 16 2009 09:27 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Quote:

Lynx wrote: (Post 2509689)
As for the actresses, both did a terrific job and really gave life to the characters. I must give Jennifer Lien special credit here, considering the fact that she was more inexperienced than Ryan but still did a terrific job. Both actresses deserves best possible credits for their efforts.

Actually, Lynx, Jen started working in her teens and had as much experience as Jeri when she came on Voyager.

I do agree with you though. While I prefer Seven, I thought both of them did a great job with what they were given.

The Grim Ghost January 16 2009 09:56 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
I liked both of them, but I thought 7 or 9 had some better episodes revolve around her. She also just had MORE episodes revolving around her, so perhaps that isn't fair. I would have liked to have seen both of them on the show together.

Captain Gandalf January 16 2009 10:27 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Quote:

Lynx wrote: (Post 2509689)

I agree that Seven was over-used and Kes under-used. But I also think that there would have been room for both of them in the series, it would actually have been interesting to see the inter-action between them.

As for the actresses, both did a terrific job and really gave life to the characters. I must give Jennifer Lien special credit here, considering the fact that she was more inexperienced than Ryan but still did a terrific job. Both actresses deserves best possible credits for their efforts.

I agree with this statement. If Kes had stayed on, it would have made more interesting stories, especially if she had developed a relationship with Seven; it's always fun to see two characters interact who are very different from each other.

Orac Zen January 16 2009 11:07 PM

Re: Kes V Seven of Nine
 
Quote:

Lynx wrote: (Post 2509689)
But I also think that there would have been room for both of them in the series, it would actually have been interesting to see the inter-action between them.

This is (basically) my response whenever this topic turns up. I like both characters and think they both brought good things to Voyager. The fact they weren't on the show together for more than an episode or two is, for mine, one of the bigger missed opportunities of the series.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:19 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.