The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=74344)

Dream November 20 2008 04:23 AM

Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
Quote:

After Bella Swan is sent to live with her father, she falls for the intriguing Edward Cullen, who she discovers is a vampire.
link
Twilight opens this Friday. You may have heard of it.

One of my friends has been talking about alot it which means I'll be seeing it eventually in the next few days. I already have a vague interest in vampires already since I'm a big Buffy and Angel fan so I'm curious. With Potter and Star Trek XI being moved to next summer there a real lack of scifi and fantasy movies this winter. Hope it's good.

ialfan November 20 2008 04:38 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I've already got tickets for me and some friends of mine Friday night!

Dream November 21 2008 09:36 PM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I'm reading the first book since I usually read the book before seeing the movie. It's fun. Since I saw the trailer first it's nice that I already think of Bella like Kristen Stewart and Edward as Robert Pattinson. :)

ialfan November 22 2008 06:32 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I saw the movie tonight. There was actually a huge line to get into the theater a full hour before the movie started that I had to wait half an hour in before we were allowed to take our seats. Overall the movie was great and very true to the book. The characterizations were pretty much spot on for me even if I still have a reservation or two about Bella. The guy playing Jacob isn't at all how I imagined him either.

My two biggest gripes about the movie are the special effect used for Edward in the sunlight is very weak and not at all how I imagined it and the movie should have been longer. Many of my favorite scenes were trimmed or cut entirely and I found myself thinking of lines unspoken. I worry that when New Moon gets made into a movie it will be even more painfully obvious the amount of material that is cut for time.

Overall: Above Average (very close to excellent)

Mr Light November 22 2008 03:56 PM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
My GF who read all the books went to see it on opening night and she said it was awful, just silly and hammy with almost no action and really bad special effects.

bullethead November 22 2008 04:53 PM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
Quote:

Mr Light wrote: (Post 2324087)
My GF who read all the books went to see it on opening night and she said it was awful, just silly and hammy with almost no action and really bad special effects.

It's a bloody teen romance movie with vampires and werewolves tacked on. It should come as no surprise that it sucks.

theenglish November 22 2008 05:28 PM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I followed the unofficial TrekBBS rules and voted based on the premise rather than an actual viewing of the movie. So there!

Peak November 23 2008 01:09 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
My preferences, and Rottentomates, leads me to another Vampire-flick (where the book is better, but when isn't it?)

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/twilight/

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/lat_den_ratte_komma_in/

Dream November 23 2008 02:14 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I just saw the movie. Above Average.

I liked it. Since I checked out the book beforehand I didn't have any problems following the story. I think the movie follows the book closely for the most part but I can't say which is better so I'll say they are just different. I can't believe that some people are complaining about the lack of action since it was the same way in the book. The romance was okay and the vampires were cool. I always liked that in this universe there are no the stake through the heart and sunlight kills stuff that usually goes with the vampire thing. The vampires playing baseball was goofy in the book but it wasn't too over the top in the movie. The best parts of the movie were definitely the music, mood, and cinematography. Kristen Stewart as Bella and Robert Pattinson as Edward were good. Bella is cute so it was a plus that she was onscreen for like 95% of the movie. Glad I saw it. :techman:

marillion November 23 2008 03:49 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I posted "Excellant" for my daughter who saw it today. She's 11 and is a huge Twilight fan... She and my wife had nothing but glowing things to say about the movie and she's dying to see it again, which is rare...

Me? I took my son to see Bolt... That was a fun little movie...

Dream November 23 2008 04:38 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
Quote:

ialfan wrote: (Post 2323176)
Many of my favorite scenes were trimmed or cut entirely and I found myself thinking of lines unspoken.

Yeah, I was a little bummed that they didn't talk about Alice's backstory in the movie. It was really important in the book and only would have taken a few minutes to explain in the movie.

I think the actress that plays Alice was great though. Nearly all the supporting cast did a good job.

Dream November 23 2008 10:55 PM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
Quote:

It was an epic weekend for the ultimate teen "chick flick," Twilight, which racked up over $70.5 million in ticket sales. Summit Entertainment has already announced New Moon, the sequel.

It was the best opening weekend ever for a female director. Catherine Hardwicke, whom I talked to for a story today, TAKE a bow!
http://blogs.orlandosentinel.com/ent...0-million.html

Number one movie of the weekend. Summit Entertainment has got to be really happy that Potter moved to next Summer. In any case glad to see the movie doing well. :rommie:

Captain Craig November 23 2008 11:35 PM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
AVERAGE

****Possible Spoilers*****
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

I give high marks to the cinematographer and fond the actor playing Carlyle Cullen to be the most interesting vamp. My date told me he has 400yrs of history. That coupled with his restraint, teachings, profession despite being a vamp and self control make him the most interesting imo.

Alice and Jessica are both more attractive than Bella. Ok except the scene in her underwear maybe.http://www.shakefire.com/boards/images/smilies/wink.gif Kristen Stewart should age well though.

The trio of bad guys come across as very 2-dimensional. James is only lacking a mustache to twill. There is no reason, despite the so thin it doesn't hold up one, that James should want to track Bella across 3 states to kill her. He has never met the Cullens or Edward till the 3rd act and has no reason to want to kill her for spite to show Edward up. The fact he is a crazy good tracker and once locked onto a scent must continue the hunt is one that just doesn't hold. Sorry.

Edward. I'm told by my friend his portrayal was just as it should've been. Well good, if you read the books cause I thought his performance was sub par. However, if that is how he is supposed to be I'll cut him slack. I liked the Jacob character and I'm told he becomes a werewolf, cool. I may see New Moon to see that. I also understand they travel to Italy. So maybe the sequel will eclipse(no pun intended) the first one in terms of quality and story.

Some lame dialoge. "Hold on my spidermonkey" http://www.shakefire.com/boards/imag...s/rolleyes.gif
Sorry Stephanie Meyer but Vamps need to hold to some consistency. I get if you want them "less threatning" but some elements should stay in play.
Vamps in Twilight can:
-have a reflection
-bite and draw blood without fangs
-be in the sunlight, the downside is they glitterhttp://www.shakefire.com/boards/imag...smiley-034.gif

How about crosses, garlic and silver those weren't addressed. When they were cooking Italian for Bella I tried to see if garlic was included in the ingredients.

Congrats on it making $70m+ it'll no doubt go on to make $175-200m but its an average movie. However the 12yr old girl next to me giggled through half of it out of, I guess, sheer joy on what was done right. So, in that regards kudos to the filmmakers. If that girl is any indication, and $70m likely is, then they made the movie most were expecting.

Venardhi November 24 2008 03:28 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
I took my sister and her friend to it yesterday since there ain't much to do in hawaii in the rain. I found it to be pretty terrible and imagine the source material is probably pretty much the same based on how much they loved it.

The concept is solid, and many of the characters have potential, but it is just really sloppy and safe and most of the character development feels more driven by plot than the characters themselves.

sidious618 November 24 2008 03:36 AM

Re: Twilight - Movie Discussion and Grading
 
My sister read the books and said that the movie sucked.
She said:
a- Acting was terrible.
b- Plot did not hold up.
c- It was boring.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:42 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.