The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (
-   -   LOTR musical? (

Chris227 October 9 2008 02:45 PM

LOTR musical?
I can remember this being big news a few years what happened?

Professor Zoom October 9 2008 04:48 PM

Re: LOTR musical?
I met the guy who played Gimli in the Toronto production. He and I were doing some temp work together...

I don't know what guess...the show was very expensive to produce and in the end, I bet, failed to capture the interest from the movies.

Mooch October 9 2008 09:53 PM

Re: LOTR musical?
It was very expensive and sold poorly. The Toronto run was cancelled early and followed by a short run in London as I recall.

edit: according to wikipedia, the London run was actually fairly successful.

Twilight October 9 2008 09:55 PM

Re: LOTR musical?
I've seen it!

Saw it in London in May of last year.

I *hated* it.

The stage itself though was the coolest thing I've ever seen. It was incredible - it rotated and split into multiple levels to create mountains or valleys or, say, the walls of Mordor. The costumes were gorgeous too - the production values were simply through the roof for that production.

But the play - say it with me - suuuuuuuuuccked.

It completely butchered the storyline of LOTR to the point that it was utterly incomprehensible. The entirety of The Two Towers was enacted in a 5 minute abstract dance number - I'm not joking. The dance began with the forging of Saruman's army and ended, 5 minutes later, with their defeat at Helm's deep. The next scene, as I recall, was Frodo and Sam crossing the plains of Mordor.

Whaaa?! :wtf:

Gaith October 9 2008 10:47 PM

Re: LOTR musical?
Also saw it in London; it was fantastic. The staging was a technical marvel. The story was very well-plotted for its three-hour or less running time, largely keeping the focus on the hobbits. It definitely had an epic feel, and got very moving at times.

My one quibble was that Gandalf was a bit of a jerk. He did a fair amount of exposition, and had to speak quickly to move stuff along, and while the guy was obviously trying not to copy McKellen, the Gollum guy was just as obviously doing the movie version.

Oh, and it woulda been nice if they'd licensed some Howard Shore music. A lot of the battle-type score was loud and mythic without having the film score's sense of purpose. And the songs were largely forgettable.

Okay, that was more than one quibble, but I still thought it was an awesome show. Especially when you've got free tickets. ;)

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.