The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   The Next Generation (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=39)
-   -   Q Who Slice... (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=69851)

PhoenixIreland October 9 2008 02:31 AM

Q Who Slice...
 
Were the people in that slice of the Ent-D the borg cut out assimilated? to give the borg a taste for humans? See if they added to perfection?

MeanJoePhaser October 9 2008 03:39 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
They were vented into space.

Christopher October 9 2008 03:50 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

PhoenixIreland wrote: (Post 2156944)
Were the people in that slice of the Ent-D the borg cut out assimilated? to give the borg a taste for humans? See if they added to perfection?

At the time the episode was written, assimilation hadn't been conceived yet; Q states that the Borg have no interest in people, only technology, and Riker finds that the drones are incubated from infancy. So no doubt Maurice Hurley's assumption was that those 18 people had died. In retrospect, however, it's logical to assume that at least some of them were assimilated, just like the multiple other assimilated Alpha-Quadrant individuals seen in VGR.

In my recent TNG novel Greater Than the Sum, I confirmed that at least one of those 18 people was assimilated and ultimately liberated in "Unimatrix Zero."

Lt_Wandrey October 9 2008 05:23 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Some of them were at the wrong place at the wrong time and could've gotten sucked out into space or killed as the beam sliced through the ship. I agree if there were any survivors from all that they were probably assimilated right away.

Christopher October 9 2008 07:13 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

Lt_Wandrey wrote: (Post 2158832)
Some of them were at the wrong place at the wrong time and could've gotten sucked out into space or killed as the beam sliced through the ship.

Unless the cylindrical beam that extracted them was also a containment field holding in the atmosphere. The Borg may have wanted them alive for study and/or assimilation.

PhoenixIreland October 9 2008 07:56 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
I was watching a you tube clip of it and even though assimilation had not been added to the storyline at this stage it's really the only thing that makes sense to me. Why else would they cut a section out of the crew quarters? Theres no valuable technology there.

I assumed that because the tractor beam seemed really tight around the cut out section it was also acting as a forcefield keeping the air in.

I can just imagine some poor bastard walking into his living room after a shower and suddenly his quarters are in space surrounded by a forcefield being sucked towards some giant borg cube

Trekker4747 October 10 2008 01:53 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
It was always my asumption that it was because of the Borg and that slice of the ship that they started assimilating. They had those 18 people, decided to hook them up to the network and then gained Starfleet's sense of "assimilation" of cultures. Which is mostly what it is they seem to do. (Though less severely than the Borg do) And Starfleet has a sense of trying to "perfect" themselves and unify the galaxy under those protections.

So the strong ideals drilled into the heads of those 18 Starfleet/Federation officers infected the Borg so they went out and did just that and took the idea too far.

It was perfect and harmonious. Beautiful, really.

Then Voyager came and fucked that notion all up.

PhoenixIreland October 10 2008 04:16 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

Shrekker4747 wrote: (Post 2160694)
It was always my asumption that it was because of the Borg and that slice of the ship that they started assimilating. They had those 18 people, decided to hook them up to the network and then gained Starfleet's sense of "assimilation" of cultures. Which is mostly what it is they seem to do. (Though less severely than the Borg do) And Starfleet has a sense of trying to "perfect" themselves and unify the galaxy under those protections.

So the strong ideals drilled into the heads of those 18 Starfleet/Federation officers infected the Borg so they went out and did just that and took the idea too far.

It was perfect and harmonious. Beautiful, really.

Then Voyager came and fucked that notion all up.

Thats a very interesting theory, I was gonna ask if voyagers flashbacks messed with that but you answerd that in your last line:lol::lol::lol:

Maurice October 10 2008 08:56 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Or...they just sliced out a random chunk to have a look at what they were about to "consume". It was just a taste.

billcosby October 11 2008 03:57 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
I thought for sure Voyager had run into plenty of borg that were former Federation members, linking to TNG episodes.

M'Sharak October 11 2008 04:25 AM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

DS9Sega wrote: (Post 2161745)
Or...they just sliced out a random chunk to have a look at what they were about to "consume". It was just a taste.

Hors d’oeuvres?

Christopher October 11 2008 02:33 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

billcosby wrote: (Post 2165010)
I thought for sure Voyager had run into plenty of borg that were former Federation members, linking to TNG episodes.

Several, yes. Riley from "Unity" and Laura from "Unimatrix Zero" were taken at Wolf 359. Marika in "Survival Instinct" was taken from the Excalibur in an unspecified instance that could've been Wolf 359. Seven recovered the memories of a couple of Starfleet personnel in "Infinite Regress," including at least one Wolf 359 participant as well as an ensign from the starship Tombaugh, which was assimilated with its entire crew in 2362, several years before the official first contact in "Q Who." We also met a Romulan ex-drone in "Unity" and an assimilated Klingon general in "Unimatrix Zero." So there were no specific links to any TNG episodes other than BoBW.

Sheliak October 11 2008 03:05 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
A cellular peptide cake, with mint frosting. :guffaw:

Mr. Laser Beam October 11 2008 04:30 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

M'Sharak wrote: (Post 2165107)
Quote:

DS9Sega wrote: (Post 2161745)
Or...they just sliced out a random chunk to have a look at what they were about to "consume". It was just a taste.

Hors d’oeuvres?

Drone: "Hey, I love these new snacks! Crunchy on the outside and a chewy center!"

Holdfast October 11 2008 05:17 PM

Re: Q Who Slice...
 
Quote:

M'Sharak wrote: (Post 2165107)
Quote:

DS9Sega wrote: (Post 2161745)
Or...they just sliced out a random chunk to have a look at what they were about to "consume". It was just a taste.

Hors d’oeuvres?

On the Borg scale, I think it barely qualifies as an amuse bouche. ;)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:28 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.