The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Dune: The TV series (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=239323)

Joe Washington March 1 2014 06:21 PM

Dune: The TV series
 
Would you be interested in Frank Herbert's Dune series being done as a TV show in the vein of Game of Thrones?

The show would be six seasons long with each season covering a different book in the series from Dune to Chapterhouse Dune. Each season would be 8-10 episodes long.

Do you think such a show can work? Who can you see playing the characters?

Admiral_Young March 1 2014 06:57 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
As much as I love the novels and the mini-series...I don't think it is possible to do a television series adaption. It would be just too expensive. At the time SyFy did the mini-series with John Harrison, it was the most expensive thing they had done, and I believe budget concerns are what cancelled an attempt at "God Emperor of Dune".

Out Of My Vulcan Mind March 1 2014 07:06 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Admiral_Young wrote: (Post 9308239)
It would be just too expensive.

It could be done with a Game of Thrones level budget, and I'd love to see Dune as a big budget HBO show. The $20 million budget for the Sci-Fi mini was very expensive by their standards, but HBO has significantly more spending power.

Admiral_Young March 1 2014 07:15 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
^ If you could do it with a scaled down budget and still have it be as faithful to the novels as "Game of Thrones" seems to be, then by all means. I just don't think that would be the case with something as vast and detailed as the Dune Universe. I think though to have that work, you'd need someone as passionate about it as John Harrison was.

Pingfah March 1 2014 07:16 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Yes, and I think Dune is one of the few sci-fi epics with sufficient potential for success to make the budget worthwhile as well.

Done right it could be huge, the movie flopped because it was rubbish, not because people don't want to see Dune on the screen.

Mr. Adventure March 1 2014 07:33 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Out Of My Vulcan Mind wrote: (Post 9308281)
Quote:

Admiral_Young wrote: (Post 9308239)
It would be just too expensive.

It could be done with a Game of Thrones level budget, and I'd love to see Dune as a big budget HBO show. The $20 million budget for the Sci-Fi mini was very expensive by their standards, but HBO has significantly more spending power.

I think they spent $10 million on hats alone.

Harvey March 1 2014 07:42 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
The first three books, I think, could make a very interesting television series. But God Emperor is so introspective, I'm not sure it would work. I haven't read the fifth or sixth book, although I've had them on the shelf for over a decade. Don't they take place long after God Emperor, though? (Which, itself, takes place long after the original trilogy).

Hound of UIster March 1 2014 07:44 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
If they only started with the Butlerian Jihad trilogy.

Out Of My Vulcan Mind March 1 2014 07:51 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Admiral_Young wrote: (Post 9308317)
^ If you could do it with a scaled down budget and still have it be as faithful to the novels as "Game of Thrones" seems to be, then by all means. I just don't think that would be the case with something as vast and detailed as the Dune Universe.

Actually, I think Dune would be somewhat easier to adapt than Game of Thrones.

Jolaris March 1 2014 09:46 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Hound of UIster wrote: (Post 9308431)
If they only started with the Butlerian Jihad trilogy.

Nah, that was called Battlestar Galactica. One petulent robot is enough, at least Number One had a good excuse. Omni and Erasmus... *shudders*:wtf:

Reverend March 1 2014 09:58 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Harvey wrote: (Post 9308419)
The first three books, I think, could make a very interesting television series. But God Emperor is so introspective, I'm not sure it would work. I haven't read the fifth or sixth book, although I've had them on the shelf for over a decade. Don't they take place long after God Emperor, though? (Which, itself, takes place long after the original trilogy).

The way to do it would be to jump from the end of CoD straight into HoD and fold the broad strokes of GEoD into the narrative as backstory. Something along the lines of the "one year later" thing in BSG, where the cliffhanger and hook for the new season is finding out what the hell just happened.

A bit trickier considering you're skipping over several millennia, including Leto's entire rule, the scattering and everything in-between *and* just about every character will be long dead. Fortunately you'd have the Duncan Gholas to provide something of a bridge.

Hound of UIster March 1 2014 10:06 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Jolaris wrote: (Post 9308989)
Quote:

Hound of UIster wrote: (Post 9308431)
If they only started with the Butlerian Jihad trilogy.

Nah, that was called Battlestar Galactica. One petulent robot is enough, at least Number One had a good excuse. Omni and Erasmus... *shudders*:wtf:

To better showcase the superiority of Frank Herbert's writing over his wastrel son and his enablers, people have to see both to better realize how terrible one is.

BigJake March 1 2014 10:17 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
The Butlerian Jihad trilogy? No... no.

Part of the brilliance of the original Dune novel is that what we see happening "in frame" is just a central slice of the truly massive conflict between the Harkonnens (and their Imperial allies) and the Atreides. A lot of important things happen "off stage" (like the Atreides' raid on Geidi Prime, or the bulk of Muad'Dib's guerilla campaign against Beast Rabban), and a television series would be a great opportunity to tease some of that out... but it would be immensely hard to do well, because you'd need people doing it who could match the quality and the unique tone of Herbert.

Isolinear March 1 2014 10:51 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Hound of UIster wrote: (Post 9309067)
Quote:

Jolaris wrote: (Post 9308989)
Quote:

Hound of UIster wrote: (Post 9308431)
If they only started with the Butlerian Jihad trilogy.

Nah, that was called Battlestar Galactica. One petulent robot is enough, at least Number One had a good excuse. Omni and Erasmus... *shudders*:wtf:

To better showcase the superiority of Frank Herbert's writing over his wastrel son and his enablers, people have to see both to better realize how terrible one is.

You mean you didn't like the mechs with brainjars or Paul Atreides running away from home to join the circus? :devil:

Jolaris March 1 2014 11:11 PM

Re: Dune: The TV series
 
Quote:

Isolinear wrote: (Post 9309235)
Quote:

Hound of UIster wrote: (Post 9309067)
Quote:

Jolaris wrote: (Post 9308989)

Nah, that was called Battlestar Galactica. One petulent robot is enough, at least Number One had a good excuse. Omni and Erasmus... *shudders*:wtf:

To better showcase the superiority of Frank Herbert's writing over his wastrel son and his enablers, people have to see both to better realize how terrible one is.

You mean you didn't like the mechs with brainjars or Paul Atreides running away from home to join the circus? :devil:

To be honest though, if the show was about Abulurd "I refuse to wipe out all life on a planet and everbody hates me for the next 10 millenia" Harkonnen getting revenge on the universe I probably would watch it, he was one of very few good things...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.