The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=238429)

HIjol February 20 2014 06:37 AM

Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Should it be?...Could it be....

Ian McKellen as Hari Seldon....Ian Holm?...

Hound of UIster February 20 2014 07:03 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Miniseries.

Asbo Zaprudder February 20 2014 08:12 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Modern audiences would likely find the story lines unengaging so TPTB would feel it necessary to remove all mention of Psychohistory and turn it into a Star Wars clone with lots of space battles.

The BBC did an 8-part radio adaptation back in the 1970s. I still have the cassette tape version, which I ripped to MP3. I did wonder if you could use CGI software to add visuals but it's probably best to use your imagination.

Guy Gardener February 20 2014 08:59 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
I thought I had that, and Now I'm suddenly wondering if I only have part one.

Arrrfg!

The thing about the books is that every one was smoking.

Which is why I would cast an older Dennis Leary as Hari Seldon.

HIjol February 20 2014 09:58 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Quote:

Guy Gardener wrote: (Post 9269452)
I thought I had that, and Now I'm suddenly wondering if I only have part one.

Arrrfg!

The thing about the books is that every one was smoking.

Which is why I would cast an older Dennis Leary as Hari Seldon.


Dennis Leary...yeah...I could see that!

The Lensman February 20 2014 10:44 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
At this point I'd much rather see a "fan" production than Hollywood's inevitable bastardization of the material. Something along the lines of the H.P. Lovecraft Historical Society's approach with "The Whisperer In Darkness". Do it art deco futurism style and find a way to make any changes minimal, yet not too distracting. I think that's going to be the only way we ever get a fairly faithful version of the stories.

As for the BBC radio adaptation.....here it is:https://archive.org/details/IsaacAsi...ndationTrilogy

Timewalker February 20 2014 10:44 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
I made the mistake of trying to start this series right after getting out of a brutal sociology final in college. To this day I haven't been able to make myself read them.

Asimov's nonfiction essays were great reading, though. :)

That said... complex SF novels (or series of short stories edited to make novels, as this series was) deserve a well-planned, well-written, well-acted miniseries, as was done with Dune and Children of Dune.

Nobody in the Foundation books wore funny hats, did they?

Guy Gardener February 20 2014 10:49 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
I creamed myself when Hari was elected Prime Minister, it suddenly made the first chapter of the first novel made so much sense that there would be that much political resentment against his personage had actually ruled the Empire after a fashion for a couple decades.

Although it was remittant of Gaal Dornick not to mention this from the get go.

Guy Gardener February 20 2014 11:08 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Quote:

Timewalker wrote: (Post 9269620)
I made the mistake of trying to start this series right after getting out of a brutal sociology final in college. To this day I haven't been able to make myself read them.

Asimov's nonfiction essays were great reading, though. :)

That said... complex SF novels (or series of short stories edited to make novels, as this series was) deserve a well-planned, well-written, well-acted miniseries, as was done with Dune and Children of Dune.

Nobody in the Foundation books wore funny hats, did they?

I was so hung over, that I could only move one arm.

Flailing, I snagged the first book, and it was 120 pages later before I could rise to my feet.

(This is the same story, different day as to how I first read preacher.)

Oh look, just after I finish downloading 1 -8, I discover that i always had one to 8.

Mach5 February 20 2014 11:50 AM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Neither. Just fucking leave it be, it's perfect as it is.

Alidar Jarok February 20 2014 01:21 PM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Part of the charm of the trilogy is hard to recreate in tone in a visual medium. That being said, miniseries is the best option. I think it's too talk and exposition heavy, though.

ATimson February 20 2014 01:49 PM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Quote:

Alidar Jarok wrote: (Post 9269848)
Part of the charm of the trilogy is hard to recreate in tone in a visual medium.

Really? I could see that maybe being true for anything involving the Second Foundation, but the bulk of it seems fairly straightforward to me.

Quote:

Alidar Jarok wrote: (Post 9269848)
That being said, miniseries is the best option. I think it's too talk and exposition heavy, though.

I don't think you necessarily have to change it to "fix" that, though. There's a lot of stuff that happens off-screen; an adaptation (especially in a miniseries format) could start showing some of that instead.

Ensign_Redshirt February 20 2014 02:30 PM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Would work best as a stage production, to be honest.

Nerys Myk February 20 2014 03:24 PM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Quote:

Timewalker wrote: (Post 9269620)
I made the mistake of trying to start this series right after getting out of a brutal sociology final in college. To this day I haven't been able to make myself read them.

Asimov's nonfiction essays were great reading, though. :)

That said... complex SF novels (or series of short stories edited to make novels, as this series was) deserve a well-planned, well-written, well-acted miniseries, as was done with Dune and Children of Dune.

Nobody in the Foundation books wore funny hats, did they?

I first read it as a 12 year old about to move halfway across the world. Lost the book ( on loan from the library) and incurred my father's wrath, as the library harassing him was the last thing needed before this move. :p

Miniseries, as it's already episodic.

Admiral2 February 20 2014 10:15 PM

Re: Asimov's "Foundation" Series as TV or Movie?
 
Hollywood already ruined I, Robot. Don't give them more ideas.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:59 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.