The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Enterprise (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=37)
-   -   Temporary Brig? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=236605)

gomtuu20 January 28 2014 02:15 AM

Temporary Brig?
 
Did you ever notice that every time Archer went to the brig to talk to a prisoner, he would always let them out at the end of the conversation?

SpHeRe31459 January 28 2014 03:33 AM

Re: Temporary Brig?
 
The title of your post makes it sounds like a temporary space was setup as the brig, rather than what your post body says which is that Archer never held a person for a long time in the brig.

A brig on a ship is generally not for long term use, it's for stashing people until they can be delivered to a proper prison. So it makes sense that Archer mostly uses it as a place to stow people who can't be let loose on the ship for a while.

Then he comes to them and asks for information or whatever, and they are turned over to the custody of their people or whatever is called for by the mission. Remember, there aren't extra crew quarters to be "confined to" like there are in something much larger like a Galaxy class ship, so the Brig it is, since it's designed as secure facility.

So the idea that they are always let out at the end of conversation is mostly Hollywood shorthand, the person has been put in the brig for a while, and then we don't see them on camera since they aren't important to narrative for the time being, the next time we see them is when Archer comes to the brig to talk to them.

Avro Arrow January 28 2014 04:23 AM

Re: Temporary Brig?
 
Quote:

gomtuu20 wrote: (Post 9176407)
Did you ever notice that every time Archer went to the brig to talk to a prisoner, he would always let them out at the end of the conversation?

But sometimes he lets them out of the brig, and puts them into the airlock. I think you'd probably prefer the brig! ;)

gomtuu20 January 28 2014 05:17 AM

Re: Temporary Brig?
 
Quote:

SpHeRe31459 wrote: (Post 9176716)
The title of your post makes it sounds like a temporary space was setup as the brig, rather than what your post body says which is that Archer never held a person for a long time in the brig.

A brig on a ship is generally not for long term use, it's for stashing people until they can be delivered to a proper prison. So it makes sense that Archer mostly uses it as a place to stow people who can't be let loose on the ship for a while.

Then he comes to them and asks for information or whatever, and they are turned over to the custody of their people or whatever is called for by the mission. Remember, there aren't extra crew quarters to be "confined to" like there are in something much larger like a Galaxy class ship, so the Brig it is, since it's designed as secure facility.

So the idea that they are always let out at the end of conversation is mostly Hollywood shorthand, the person has been put in the brig for a while, and then we don't see them on camera since they aren't important to narrative for the time being, the next time we see them is when Archer comes to the brig to talk to them.


Yes, I know what a brig is. No, I'm not talking about how some people no longer seem to be in the brig. I'm talking about how he goes and talks to prisoner and then hits the button to let them out nearly every time.

SpHeRe31459 January 28 2014 05:59 AM

Re: Temporary Brig?
 
Quote:

gomtuu20 wrote: (Post 9176989)
Quote:

SpHeRe31459 wrote: (Post 9176716)
The title of your post makes it sounds like a temporary space was setup as the brig, rather than what your post body says which is that Archer never held a person for a long time in the brig.

A brig on a ship is generally not for long term use, it's for stashing people until they can be delivered to a proper prison. So it makes sense that Archer mostly uses it as a place to stow people who can't be let loose on the ship for a while.

Then he comes to them and asks for information or whatever, and they are turned over to the custody of their people or whatever is called for by the mission. Remember, there aren't extra crew quarters to be "confined to" like there are in something much larger like a Galaxy class ship, so the Brig it is, since it's designed as secure facility.

So the idea that they are always let out at the end of conversation is mostly Hollywood shorthand, the person has been put in the brig for a while, and then we don't see them on camera since they aren't important to narrative for the time being, the next time we see them is when Archer comes to the brig to talk to them.


Yes, I know what a brig is. No, I'm not talking about how some people no longer seem to be in the brig. I'm talking about how he goes and talks to prisoner and then hits the button to let them out nearly every time.

Right which I gave an explanation for at the end of my first post...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:44 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.