The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Future of Trek (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=13)
-   -   The Future of Star Trek - Animation? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=235327)

milojthatch January 12 2014 02:56 PM

The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Now, I need to say before I go too far into this, I fully understand that there are a number of Star Trek fans, especially those of the older generations, that have some issue with the idea of Star Trek being animated. There are various reasons for this, I get that, just please hear me out.

I think that the best way for Star Trek to come back to tv is via an animated show or two. I realize that some have a bad taste in their mouth from the original Star Trek: The Animated Series. Let me just say this about that: TAS was produced in a different era of animation. Had it been animated even a decade earlier, I have no doubt that the production values would have been improved. When you get past the weak animation however, the writing was actually really good, especially for a 1970's Saturday morning cartoon.

I feel that animation has come a long way, and despite the view that prime-time animation has to be funny (thanks a lot Simpsons and Family Guy), I feel it is possible to have a slightly more dramatic prime-time animated show that could be geared for both adults and older children.

Part of the reasons why Enterprise was taken off the air was due to the high production costs that an average Star Trek episode costs. The powers that be finally felt that the ratings just could not justify the production costs that frankly every live-action Star Trek show dealt with. While it would still cost money, a good quality animated show could cost a lot less than a live action show would.

Further, an animated show may literally be the only way we'd ever "see" the TNG cast or other Prime Universe actors reprise their roles again. Think about it: most of the TNG cast, besides being fine actors (or directors), have also done a lot of voice acting. All of them came back for Family Guy, and a number of them, including Patrick Stewart and Brent Spiner, have done other recent voice acting roles. I really don't think it would be such a stretch to get these guys, or the living cast members from TOS, DS9, Voyager or Enterprise, to come back as a voice actor for an animated Star Trek show.

Yet, despite the lack of live-action, as TAS showed us, there can still be really interesting Star Trek stories told with the right writers. If it's intresting enough, even some of the most anti-animation fans might find themselves forgeting they are watching a cartoon and get lost in the World of Star Trek.

With animation, we could also finally see a show that explores strange new worlds like no live-action show could ever properly show us. With the animation medium, the sky really is the limit when it comes to imagination.

Such an animated show could be aired as a prime-time show or on a cable network such as Cartoon Network or Nickelodeon. Or maybe it could even skip traditional tv and air on NetFlix!?

Lastly, an animated Trek show, if done right, could help make the case for why CBS TV should invest in a new live-action show without the cost of making a live-action show. It could also be used to help transition the fans from the characters that we all know and love to whatever the new characters are that would star on a new live-action show.

There, I've made my case, what do the rest of you think?

Some thoughts on setting for possible Star Trek animated shows:

-The post-Enterprise era
-The Romulans Wars
-The Capt. Pike era of the Enterprise
-The TOS era between the show and the films
-The era between the TOS films and TNG
-The post-Nemesis era
-Something taking place between the TOS films or between the TNG films

Mysterion January 12 2014 08:23 PM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
In a word: Yes. the current state of animation offers almost endless possibiities.

Look at what they did with The Clone Wars animated series. IMO, they really did a good job of expanding upon the live-action movie series. The same thing could certainly be done with Trek.

An animated Trek series could be set in any era, with any characters. You could have stories set in any of the series, or veer off into new characters and situations. With the right voice actors, you could even do TOS episodes.

It could even be an "anthology" type series that so many folks seem to advocate (but couldn't really work with a live-action format).

drt January 13 2014 01:11 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
I think the best chance of a commercially-viable animated property would be a Kirk/Spock show - most likely taking place during the five year mission.

milojthatch January 13 2014 08:57 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Just a little something to wet the animated Star Trek appetite...
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-_EWFCEitL6.../TNG_ANIME.jpg

C.E. Evans January 14 2014 12:17 PM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
I'd love to see a Trek animated series aimed at a younger crowd (6-13) with all the toys and other related merchandise (video games, books, apparel, etc.) associated with it. Set in its own continuity, it could take a few cues from the current movies however.

bbjeg January 14 2014 12:40 PM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
I would soo watch that milojthatch.

Taranis January 14 2014 12:56 PM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Quote:

milojthatch wrote: (Post 9113530)
There, I've made my case, what do the rest of you think?

Some thoughts on setting for possible Star Trek animated shows:

-The post-Enterprise era
-The Romulans Wars
-The Capt. Pike era of the Enterprise
-The TOS era between the show and the films
-The era between the TOS films and TNG
-The post-Nemesis era
-Something taking place between the TOS films or between the TNG films

I have no problem with seen a Star Trek animated show.

I am more partial to
-The TOS era between the show and the films-
or
TNG before the destruction of the Enterprise D.. I am not that hot on the E.. personal preference.

T'Girl January 14 2014 10:41 PM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
A young Federation series might be damned interesting.


:)

Hober Mallow January 16 2014 01:22 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
I think animation is the future of Star Trek, but it's going to be -- and should be -- a reboot. Berman-Trek is done.

T'Girl January 16 2014 01:46 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Quote:

Hober Mallow wrote: (Post 9128113)
... reboot ...

Okay, reboot to where in your mind? All the way back to The Cage? How much or little would you want to keep?


:)

Hober Mallow January 16 2014 01:53 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Quote:

T'Girl wrote: (Post 9128206)
Quote:

Hober Mallow wrote: (Post 9128113)
... reboot ...

Okay, reboot to where in your mind? All the way back to The Cage? How much or little would you want to keep?


:)

To the source material -- Kirk and Spock on the Enterprise exploring strange new worlds.

Shaka Zulu January 16 2014 02:42 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Quote:

milojthatch wrote: (Post 9116953)
Just a little something to wet the animated Star Trek appetite...
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-_EWFCEitL6.../TNG_ANIME.jpg

Holy shit, that looks just like the DCAU animation style (Batman: The Animated Series, Superman; The Animated Series, Justice League, Justice League Unlimited, The Batman, Batman Beyond
, etc. Maybe CBS could set up its own animation studio and hire away Bruce Timn and Paul Dini as showrunners. :cool::techman:

Only one problem, though, for the show shown in the picture, would the cast members want to do voices of the characters, especially considering that Stewart and Spiner basically said good-bye to their roles with Nemesis? If they don', other actors might have to be hired to do the voices of Picard & Data, or all of the characters if the originals don't want to come back (although this might solve Michael Dorn's problem of coming back as Worf.)

BigJake January 16 2014 02:55 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
I'm all over the idea of an animated series. And actually... a TNG animated series might be interesting. Though I'd be fine with an animated series in a TOS continuity too.

T'Girl January 16 2014 03:44 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
Maybe they can hire that guy why does the voice overs for those Car Rental commercials to voice Picard, he does sound like Stewart.



:)

drt January 16 2014 11:48 AM

Re: The Future of Star Trek - Animation?
 
I'd be OK with voice actors, I don't need the originals. Makes everything easier to produce.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:53 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.