The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science and Technology (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=36)
-   -   Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=232162)

Snaploud December 2 2013 03:52 AM

Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/1...n_4369685.html

Interesting stuff. There's a cool video in the link. Their big concern is getting FAA approval, but Bezos is hoping to have this service in place in 4-5 years.

Edit: Here are more details from the WashingtonPost.com:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/...s-with-drones/

Mr. Laser Beam December 2 2013 04:54 AM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Operation "This Will Likely End Badly" is a go, apparently.

Never mind the obvious things, like bad weather and noise. What happens if one of these things gets 1) shot at, 2) stolen, or 3) crashes into somebody's house? The liability issues alone would be off the charts.

At least human drivers have some discretion over where they leave packages. If they consider a house or neighborhood unsafe or insecure, they won't leave the package. A drone can't do that, obviously.

Tribble puncher December 2 2013 06:34 AM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 8964325)
Operation "This Will Likely End Badly" is a go, apparently.

Never mind the obvious things, like bad weather and noise. What happens if one of these things gets 1) shot at, 2) stolen, or 3) crashes into somebody's house? The liability issues alone would be off the charts.

At least human drivers have some discretion over where they leave packages. If they consider a house or neighborhood unsafe or insecure, they won't leave the package. A drone can't do that, obviously.

everything you said I thought....

Kronos December 2 2013 07:41 AM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
How long until UPS or FedEX deploy missiles to shoot these down? ;)

PurpleBuddha December 2 2013 08:49 AM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

Tribble puncher wrote: (Post 8964595)
Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 8964325)
Operation "This Will Likely End Badly" is a go, apparently.

Never mind the obvious things, like bad weather and noise. What happens if one of these things gets 1) shot at, 2) stolen, or 3) crashes into somebody's house? The liability issues alone would be off the charts.

At least human drivers have some discretion over where they leave packages. If they consider a house or neighborhood unsafe or insecure, they won't leave the package. A drone can't do that, obviously.

everything you said I thought....

These drone deliveries would very likely be statistically more safe than drivers delivering the same packages. That of course would not stop the bad press that would follow any such accident.

For theft, I suppose the camera in the drone along with gps would deter many people, but this would be a real issue. I imagine some people could get quite skilled at poaching these packages, the same way they currently do with traditional deliveries. It would be an on going issue.

However, Amazon could take the risk. Part of the service will likely involve a small insurance fee built into the cost of 30 minute air delivery. Since Amazon will know via gps if the package made it or not they would know if you needed to be reimbursed for a failure. They may even have gps tracking software planned where you could watch a little line on your monitor as it shows the real time position of your package en route your house.

The instincts of the driver aren't a big concern. If you are ordering 30 minute service you are more likely to get your package right as it is set down at your door. If it sits there for half the day or even a couple hours as is common with normal deliveries, that would be more risky even in a "nice" neighborhood.

Edit to add: Given how big a factor the wind alone would be, never mind other weather types, the availability of this service would be significantly limited until such a time that the tech is vastly improved.

Metryq December 2 2013 11:07 AM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

PurpleBuddha wrote: (Post 8964799)
If you are ordering 30 minute service you are more likely to get your package right as it is set down at your door.

My thoughts, exactly, concerning "theft." In the same vein, how many pizzas sit around on a doorstep, even in a good neighborhood, for several hours?

How many people will be injured by trying to approach the drone as it descends?

I live in a very small town, and our cable access station is equally very small. While considering new equipment, one of the board members suggested a quad-copter with camera to get some exotic shots of the Memorial Day parade, kids' field games, etc. Fly over crowds? The idea was quickly shot down on insurance arguments.

One more thought: What's the weight limit on that service?

Edit: 60 MINUTES exclusive, hmmm. Prided as a serious news show, the program is also a "magazine" format. This "news" is nothing less than free advertising for Amazon.

Robert Maxwell December 2 2013 01:28 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

Metryq wrote: (Post 8965057)
One more thought: What's the weight limit on that service?

You know, all you had to do was read the HuffPo article to learn that. They're looking at delivering packages of up to 5 pounds, which apparently represents most of their orders.

It's too early in all this to start poopooing as-yet-unseen technology. Amazon's not stupid. I'm sure they are taking all the noted concerns into account, as well as concerns no one here has voiced. Amazon hires a lot of smart people, you know. ;)

It may be successful, it may not. It really depends on how well they can mitigate any risks, and whether they can get government approval to fly little drones all over the place.

Metryq December 2 2013 01:47 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

Robert Maxwell wrote: (Post 8965207)
Quote:

Metryq wrote: (Post 8965057)
One more thought: What's the weight limit on that service?

You know, all you had to do was read the HuffPo article to learn that.

Forgive me. I read a shorter blurb on the story from another site.

DarthTom December 2 2013 03:22 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
35% of Americans live in apartment buildings of which 44% represent more than 5 units. Apartment dwelling soars among people under 30 to over 40% as well. I'm not sure what Amazon's demos are - who's buying - and in what cities - but this plan seems costly and far fetched considering it's impratical for so many of their customers;

Stats on apartment rentals and general housing demos

Robert Maxwell December 2 2013 03:26 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
I live in an apartment building, and I assure you it's not hard to get packages delivered. I'm not sure what point you are trying to make.

DarthTom December 2 2013 03:28 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

Robert Maxwell wrote: (Post 8965378)
I live in an apartment building, and I assure you it's not hard to get packages delivered. I'm not sure what point you are trying to make.

Doesn't Fed Ex or other delivery companies place the package inside a common hallway? A drone wouldn't perform such a task.

Robert Maxwell December 2 2013 03:31 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
We are talking about communication-enabled drones here. What, a drone can't just text you, "I'm outside, please come get your package" and hover for a few minutes?

Use your imaginations, people. ;)

Mr. Laser Beam December 2 2013 04:12 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
The noise these things would surely generate would be all the alert you'd need that they're out there.

DarthTom December 2 2013 05:16 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

Robert Maxwell wrote: (Post 8965396)
We are talking about communication-enabled drones here. What, a drone can't just text you, "I'm outside, please come get your package" and hover for a few minutes?

Use your imaginations, people. ;)

I got it. I'm just not seeing how this could work in a urban enivornment like Los Angeles or New York. These drones have the potential of being distracting to drivers and even pedestrians when you get into densely populated areas.

I'll give Bezos credit for thinking ahead and potentially re-creating Amazon's business model from 24 hour delivery to virtually instant delivery.

I dunno man - most shit that I need in 30 minutes or less I'd get in the car instead and buy.

PurpleBuddha December 2 2013 06:52 PM

Re: Amazon Prime Air Delivery Drones Revealed By CEO Jeff Bezos
 
Quote:

DarthTom wrote: (Post 8965714)
Quote:

Robert Maxwell wrote: (Post 8965396)
We are talking about communication-enabled drones here. What, a drone can't just text you, "I'm outside, please come get your package" and hover for a few minutes?

Use your imaginations, people. ;)

I got it. I'm just not seeing how this could work in a urban enivornment like Los Angeles or New York. These drones have the potential of being distracting to drivers and even pedestrians when you get into densely populated areas.

I'll give Bezos credit for thinking ahead and potentially re-creating Amazon's business model from 24 hour delivery to virtually instant delivery.

I dunno man - most shit that I need in 30 minutes or less I'd get in the car instead and buy.

And if this takes off in a way that works (that is a big if), people will fall in love with this convenience. It will become another part of society, and we will all get to reminisce about how the neighborhood sky used to be drone free, with drones mainly being used only to kill people or spy....the way it should be. :)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.