The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek - Original Series (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   Joanna McCoy (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=226315)

CaptainBearclaw September 19 2013 12:49 AM

Joanna McCoy
 
New post at my blog: an analysis of McCoy's long lost daughter.

http://startrekrarities.blogspot.com...nna-mccoy.html

Harvey September 19 2013 01:07 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
One point of correction -- D.C. Fontana didn't "only help out on two Season 3 episodes," and without credit. She wrote the story and teleplay for 'The Enterprise Incident.' She received story credit for 'That Which Survives' (from her outline, "Survival') and 'The Way to Eden' (from her outline and teleplay, 'Joanna'). In both of those cases, though, she was unhappy with how she was rewritten, and she opted to use her pseudonym, Michael Richards (I've read that she wanted to use her pseudonym on 'The Enterprise Incident,' too, but Roddenberry talked her out of it).

GSchnitzer September 19 2013 01:13 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Quote:

Harvey wrote: (Post 8664169)
One point of correction -- D.C. Fontana didn't "only help out on two Season 3 episodes," and without credit. She wrote the story and teleplay for 'The Enterprise Incident.' She received story credit for 'That Which Survives' (from her outline, "Survival') and 'The Way to Eden' (from her outline and teleplay, 'Joanna'). In both of those cases, though, she was unhappy with how she was rewritten, and she opted to use her pseudonym, Arthur Richards (I've read that she wanted to use her pseudonym on 'The Enterprise Incident,' too, but Roddenberry talked her out of it).

Michael Richards--not Arthur. ;)

Kinokima September 19 2013 01:14 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Well I am certainly glad that they didn't go with the storyline of Spock accidentally kills McCoy's daughter that would have been awful. And honestly I dislike stories where a family member is introduced and then subsequently killed, it's cheap drama in my opinion.

Not sure how I would have felt about Kirk falling for McCoy's daughter either. That could have been very good or very bad depending on how it was handled.

But as a McCoy fan I am disappointed Joanna never worked out in the story. I think if given the right story it could have given Kelley an interesting storyline to work with. From what I understand Joanna was originally envisioned to be a son, but it was De Kelley who suggested a daughter for McCoy instead. Too bad it never came to fruition.

And yes I know Joanna was mentioned in one of the animated episodes, but a couple lines hardly counts to me.

Finally I did get a good laugh when someone mentioned something at a convention in the 80's and De Kelley made a joke that they took so long, Joanna is now a grandmother.

Harvey September 19 2013 01:25 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Quote:

GSchnitzer wrote: (Post 8664178)
Quote:

Harvey wrote: (Post 8664169)
One point of correction -- D.C. Fontana didn't "only help out on two Season 3 episodes," and without credit. She wrote the story and teleplay for 'The Enterprise Incident.' She received story credit for 'That Which Survives' (from her outline, "Survival') and 'The Way to Eden' (from her outline and teleplay, 'Joanna'). In both of those cases, though, she was unhappy with how she was rewritten, and she opted to use her pseudonym, Arthur Richards (I've read that she wanted to use her pseudonym on 'The Enterprise Incident,' too, but Roddenberry talked her out of it).

Michael Richards--not Arthur. ;)

Oops. Fixed.

CaptainBearclaw September 19 2013 02:29 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Quote:

Harvey wrote: (Post 8664169)
One point of correction -- D.C. Fontana didn't "only help out on two Season 3 episodes," and without credit. She wrote the story and teleplay for 'The Enterprise Incident.' She received story credit for 'That Which Survives' (from her outline, "Survival') and 'The Way to Eden' (from her outline and teleplay, 'Joanna'). In both of those cases, though, she was unhappy with how she was rewritten, and she opted to use her pseudonym, Michael Richards (I've read that she wanted to use her pseudonym on 'The Enterprise Incident,' too, but Roddenberry talked her out of it).

Thanks! I thought I might've gotten that wrong. Fixed.

Warped9 September 19 2013 05:15 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Kirk getting involved with McCoy's daughter---I always thought that would be Eeeeww!!!

George Steinbrenner September 19 2013 05:21 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
^ Indeed. Where's Chris Hansen when you need him? :wtf:

Push The Button September 19 2013 05:37 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Joanna is in "Crucible: Provenance of Shadows", which if you aren't familiar with it, is a McCoy-centric novel that takes place during the timeframe of TOS. I was about half-way through it, then life intervened and I set it aside.

mythme September 19 2013 05:43 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Although not mentioned by name, McCoy does say he has a daughter in "The Survivor" episode of the Animated Series.

Geoff Peterson September 19 2013 05:46 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Quote:

Warped9 wrote: (Post 8664934)
Kirk getting involved with McCoy's daughter---I always thought that would be Eeeeww!!!

Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 8664958)
^ Indeed. Where's Chris Hansen when you need him? :wtf:

Was it Eeeewww when Kirk was involved with the 19 year old Lenore Karidian?

mythme September 19 2013 05:48 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Then again, to me Kirk was a bit TOO "friendly" with Miri

Kinokima September 19 2013 11:27 AM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Kirk was in his early to mid 30's and Joanna was a nursing student, either 19 or 20. This is not like we are taking pedophilia. She was young but still an adult. And their age difference was not that severe. People get married with a larger age difference than that.

McCoy was about 10 years older then Kirk. The point of the storyline was Mccoy was supposed to see Kirk in the eyes of a father.

It could have been potentially interesting. My worry would have been I really like the Kirk/McCoy relationship & friendship in TOS and I wouldn't want anything to ruin that.

Christopher September 19 2013 03:28 PM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Quote:

Nerys Myk wrote: (Post 8664994)
Was it Eeeewww when Kirk was involved with the 19 year old Lenore Karidian?

Whoa, I didn't realize that. And Barbara Anderson was not quite 21 when the episode was filmed.

George Steinbrenner September 19 2013 03:35 PM

Re: Joanna McCoy
 
Quote:

Nerys Myk wrote: (Post 8664994)
Quote:

Warped9 wrote: (Post 8664934)
Kirk getting involved with McCoy's daughter---I always thought that would be Eeeeww!!!

Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 8664958)
^ Indeed. Where's Chris Hansen when you need him? :wtf:

Was it Eeeewww when Kirk was involved with the 19 year old Lenore Karidian?

I didn't know McCoy was older enough than Kirk to have a daughter that Kirk could legitimately be involved with. In TOS, he's not quite 40 (he was born in 2227).

I suppose it would work - in TOS. Not yet in the Abramsverse though! As of the end of STID, Joanna - assuming she exists - is probably about 11 or 12 at most.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:44 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.