The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek Movies XI+ (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=50)
-   -   Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=226081)

Flying Spaghetti Monster September 16 2013 06:17 PM

Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
This is a really interesting article.

LINK

I actually embrace the story angle of Section 31, and the challenging whether Gene's vision is sustainable. That said, the writer does have a point, that maybe the new timeline hasn't earned this quite yet.

Locutus of Bored September 16 2013 11:24 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
The writer acknowledges that darker aspects of Starfleet and the Federation have been dealt with outside of DS9 with one whole (rather dismissive) sentence, but then treats that as an exceptional aspect of DS9. I agree that DS9 explored that dark side in greater depth, but it's hardly exclusive to that series (Cartright and the Khitomer conspiracy in particular come to mind as a comparison to Marcus, but there are many more examples) and STiD. The writer just kind of conveniently glosses over the points that don't fit their premise.

Bad Thoughts September 17 2013 12:32 AM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
Considering DS9 buried heroism and denied the possibility of militancy being a positive force in the last episode, I wonder if the author even thought about the similarity of the series to the reboot. Saying that they were both dark trivialize DS9, which was still very much in the Roddenberry universe, testing idealism rather than ignoring it.

King Daniel Into Darkness September 17 2013 11:39 AM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
Wrath of Khan worked perfectly as a standalone film, just as Into Darkness does. DS9, a couple of crossover episodes aside, works as a standalone series. All that "earned" stuff is nonsense, IMO. "Space Seed" was optional backstory at best to WoK, just as TNG is to DS9 and the whole lot of Trek is to Abrams' movies.

dub September 17 2013 02:01 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
The use of Section 31 is where the similarities end. Unless...unless the alternate universe of nuTrek is actually the Mirror Universe, and we're seeing the prequels! If nuSpock starts growing a van dyke in nuTrekIII, we'll know!

Bad Thoughts September 17 2013 02:06 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
Quote:

dub wrote: (Post 8657236)
The use of Section 31 is where the similarities end. Unless...unless the alternate universe of nuTrek is actually the Mirror Universe, and we're seeing the prequels! If nuSpock starts growing a van dyke in nuTrekIII, we'll know!

Maybe nuHura can drag him around on a leash.

The Wormhole September 17 2013 02:34 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
I only glanced over that article, but Starfleet having darker aspects is hardly unique to DS9. Just look how often we saw renegade Captains or Admirals on TOS, TNG, their movies, and even Voyager.

The shows themselves often portray the crews of that particular series' hero ship as noble and virtuous but Starfleet in general has often been rather shady with less than ideal officers achieving high ranks. Hell, often whenever a captain or admiral has gone rogue and the line "impossible, he's a decorated officer" is used, that to me is a red flag that it most certainly is possible. In many ways Starfleet is much like the Time Lords on Doctor Who with how many renegades exist within something supposed to be the most noble and enlightened people in their respective universes.

Hober Mallow September 17 2013 03:58 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
Quote:

Locutus of Bored wrote: (Post 8654827)
The writer acknowledges that darker aspects of Starfleet and the Federation have been dealt with outside of DS9 with one whole (rather dismissive) sentence, but then treats that as an exceptional aspect of DS9. I agree that DS9 explored that dark side in greater depth, but it's hardly exclusive to that series (Cartright and the Khitomer conspiracy in particular come to mind as a comparison to Marcus, but there are many more examples) and STiD. The writer just kind of conveniently glosses over the points that don't fit their premise.

Yeah, Nick Meyer gave us a darker vision of Star Trek long before DS9.

The Keeper September 17 2013 07:42 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
Quote:

LAUREN DAVIS wrote wrote:
But what makes Deep Space Nine something greater than it would be as a standalone show, what makes it great Star Trek, is that it stands as a counterpoint to the TV shows and movies that came before it.

Using her comparison method; if DS9 served as a counterpoint to all the Trek which came before it then couldn't NuTrek be viewed as a counterpoint to the entire Primeline?

King Daniel Into Darkness September 17 2013 08:53 PM

Re: Article on STiD becoming like Deep Space Nine
 
^Very much so:bolian:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.