The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Trek Literature (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=43)
-   -   Spoiler Poll (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=225694)

JD September 13 2013 06:27 AM

Spoiler Poll
 
Even though I'm a supporter of the 6-month rule, I decided to do this since none of the anti-spoiler people will.

R. Star September 13 2013 06:50 AM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Use common sense. If you're talking on a discussion thread about the novel talk away. If you're on another thread it's polite to tag any significant plot twists. Forbid the effort of a couple extra mouse clicks to tag something.

Dimesdan September 13 2013 08:24 AM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Quote:

JD wrote: (Post 8638621)
Even though I'm a supporter of the 6-month rule, I decided to do this since none of the anti-spoiler people will.

You know, although doing a poll on the matter is a good idea, your wording of your original post comes across as pretty passive aggressive and petty.

As I started the spoilers, a discussion thread, I did think about doing a poll, but thought better of it as I prefer discussion over posting in a poll as that way you can gauge a persons opinion more as it forces them to explain themselves.

But yes, the six months rule is the best option and maybe the two threads could be merged?

Scout101 September 13 2013 11:57 AM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Somewhere between 6 months and just use your own discretion. As in, no code needed if you're in a thread that says it contains spoilers. As that's the point of being in that thread, you can talk openly about what happened there.

And obviously NEVER in a thread title, at least if it can be avoided. I guess if you, for example, want to ask a question about
, it could be considered spoiler-ish about the current state of that issue vice where the show left off. I guess 6 month rule works there, nothing in the open that's new, and avoid it as best as possible for thread titles.

trampledamage September 13 2013 02:09 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Quote:

Dimesdan wrote: (Post 8638762)
maybe the two threads could be merged?

I'm going to leave them separate - quite often it works well to have a different discussion thread to the voting thread.

Garrovick September 13 2013 02:51 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
I had a hard time deciding between 6-months and use-your-own-discretion, but I came down on the discretion side because I feel that 6 months is just too short a period - I'd probably have an easier time supporting a 12-month rule.

That having been said, I do think having a 6-month rule is much preferable to having a "code all spoilers" or "code no spoilers" rule.

Whenever I post about something, I probably tend to err on the side of caution and spoiler-code things that others may feel don't need them. But I don't expect everyone to follow my way and I wouldn't get upset if I accidentally got spoiled by reading something about a book that is, say, 5 or 10 years old that I just don't happen to have read yet. I've read just about everything published since the "A Time To..." series except for Vanguard and NF, but there's a lot of stuff from about 1998-2004 that I haven't read yet (working on it, though). I understand that coming to this forum carries the potential of accidential spoilage and I'm prepared to accept that risk.

I do definitely support the idea of blanket spoiler warnings for threads involving new books and I feel entering those threads before you've read the book should be at your own risk. I will visit those threads before the book is actually published to see the artwork and see how others feel about the book, but once it is actually out I stay away from the thread until I've read the book. It's worked pretty well for me so far.

jpv2000 September 13 2013 03:06 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
I went with "use you own discretion" as I usually err on the side of caution.

I think six months is fine and posting open spoilers in a thread clearly marked for spoilers for a certain topic is fine.

I put a post about the ending of "Synthesis" in spoiler code just yesterday. As I had just finished it I thought there might be others in the same boat. I did so because the thread wasn't about "Synthesis" and I wanted to play it safe for others sake.

DonIago September 13 2013 03:33 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
I'm not really sure how I feel about this though I support the idea of a poll in general terms...but then, I simply avoid reading threads that seem to be about books I haven't read.

I do wish the poll included additional options such as 1 year, though.

shanejayell September 13 2013 05:54 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
I don't think I want a hard and fast date rule. Voted 'own discression.'

Reanok September 13 2013 06:57 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Use your own discretion when it comes to spoilers .That's what I voted for. If your interested in a novel and read spoilers for books in any series are curious that's up to the person who wants to more about the continued storylines like the upcoming TNG/Ds9 The fall book series.

JWolf September 13 2013 09:15 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Given that the poll isn't multiple choice, I'm going with best judgement because not all spoilers are going to cause a book to be spoiled. But I do feel that the moderators would need to take an active roll when an an open spoiler is reported as being in need of a spoiler code. If a spoiler is reported, it should be then put in a spoiler code as someone feels it's too big a spoiler to be out in the open. If reported spoilers don't get fixed, then we'll be back to the same mess we are in now.

DonIago September 13 2013 09:17 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
^Nobody's stopping you from posting your own.

JWolf September 13 2013 09:25 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Given the current results, it's 14 - 12 against a six month rule.

DonIago September 13 2013 09:34 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
It's also 50% in favor of "use your own discretion", which based on your own posting history is not an approach that you would seem to prefer. Presumably you'd prefer it even less if and when posters felt that six months was more than they felt they should be held to.

Based on our prior discussion it increasingly seems to me that you're upset because you tried to upbraid someone for posting spoilers that you felt should not have been posted only to have it boomerang on you when they proceeded to ask the moderators to clarify spoiler-posting policy and it didn't work out to your satisfaction.

Sran September 13 2013 09:37 PM

Re: Spoiler Poll
 
Quote:

JWolf wrote: (Post 8641342)
Given the current results, it's 14 - 12 against a six month rule.

That's not what it looks like to me.

Quote:

DonIago wrote:
It's also 50% in favor of "use your own discretion", which based on your own posting history is not an approach that you would seem to prefer. Presumably you'd prefer it even less if and when posters felt that six months was more than they felt they should be held to.

I was going to post this, but you've already taken care of it. Well done.

--Sran


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.