The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Future of Trek (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=13)
-   -   Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=225439)

VOODOOXI September 10 2013 09:31 PM

Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
I agree with everything in the article...TNG back on tv is the only sure fire winner the franchise has to offer.

[COLOR=#bababa]http://www.rollingstone.com/movies/n...ation-20130910
[/COLOR]

BillJ September 10 2013 09:35 PM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Bring back Frakes and Company? I'm sorry, that's just a one-way ticket to disaster. TV has changed mightily since TNG's run.

Borgminister September 11 2013 12:51 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
No. Wishful thinking aside, it won't fly.

Kenbushway September 11 2013 03:28 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
TNG was a more peaceful star trek show than the original tv series. I think it was successful partly because it took on a more peaceful stance during the cold war era, it tied into the people's feeling of not wanting conflict. Would that fit in today? Yes and no.. I don't think that the TNG would be entirely successful because while many want peace it goes back to the audiences of tv and movies wanting more shoot first and ask questions later; the exact opposite of what the TNG series brought. I also don't think anyone could beat or even match Patrick Stewart or any of the original crew to be honest.

StarMan September 11 2013 05:54 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
This premise could be tweaked into something workable, IMO. My first thoughts would be new captain and central characters - maybe a couple of leftovers from TNG crew (first thought - Geordi). I like Picard as admiral. However, I'd prefer the idea of a more adult, serialized take in a similar vein to DS9. Yes, the Enterprise can boldly go, but have it set against a bigger story.

Galileo7 September 11 2013 08:56 PM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Quote:

BillJ wrote: (Post 8627557)
Bring back Frakes and Company? I'm sorry, that's just a one-way ticket to disaster. TV has changed mightily since TNG's run.

Agree.:klingon:

R. Star September 11 2013 09:15 PM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
I don't mind a post Nemesis set series at all. You could have the old TNG/DS9/VOY crews make the occasional cameos, but frankly they're really all too old to carry a series by themselves. That was true ten years ago in Nemesis.

That said, Rolling Stone's reader base these days is fairly negligible, so their "call" probably won't even reach the CBS exec's desk.

Frontier September 11 2013 11:55 PM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Give Michael Dorn his Captain Worf show. Set it 20 years after Nemesis. Make the ship a long range tactical explorer; a ship with fierce teeth meant to push the boundaries of exploration while at the same time protecting the UFP from threats before they get to close. Get one person from DS9 and one from Voyager. Maybe Tim Russ as Tuvok at Tactical, Aron Eisenberg as Nog in Engineering. Or hell, maybe Naomi Wildman all grown up and in Starfleet. She grew up nicely. Ahem. Give Worf a new character female XO, and fill out the ranks with other new people/young people. Have frequent cameos from other Trek alumni as their characters. Admiral Janeway. Ambassador Picard. Captain Riker and Cmdr. Troi of the Titan. Professor Rej Barclay at the Academy. Captain La Forge of the Challenger. The Doctor. Captain Kira at DS9. So on and so forth.

You can't just toss most of the TNG cast back into their suits and go. I don't think Spiner would do it, I know Stewart wouldn't do it but once and a while to be with his friends. Frakes isn't young enough to carry the center chair. Hollywood BS won't allow you to have two female leads in their 50s like Marina and Gates. Not sure Levar Burton would go back unless you suggested Captain La Forge show, lol.

Dorn wants back in. Tim Russ has been doing fan stuff, so he wants back in. A fair number of the alumni want back in, and will be easy to sign up. Take them, do what you can, fill out the rest with new young eye-candy to draw the kids in. There are only a handful of alumni who don't want such; Shatner, Stewart, Nimoy, Spiner, Beltran. McNeill and Dawson are both behind the scenes now. Siddig and Meaney are doing well career wise. Other than those... you've got your pick.

Basically, it's following the "Dallas" route. Only with a much bigger ensemble to trot in and out now and then, and 3 shows to spin-off rather than one, while keeping TNG at it's core by having Worf as Captain.

BillJ September 11 2013 11:57 PM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Quote:

Frontier wrote: (Post 8633089)
Give Michael Dorn his Captain Worf show. Set it 20 years after Nemesis. Get one person from DS9 and one from Voyager. Maybe Tim Russ as Tuvok at Tactical, Aron Eisenberg as Nog in Engineering. Give Worf a new character female XO, and fill out the ranks with other new people/young people. Have frequent cameos from other Trek alumni as their characters. Admiral Janeway. Ambassador Picard. Captain Riker and Cmdr. Troi of the Titan. Professor Rej Barclay at the Academy. Captain La Forge of the Challenger. The Doctor. Captain Kira at DS9. So on and so forth.

Oh God, no!

That just sounds plain terrible.

jpv2000 September 12 2013 12:36 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
I posted this in the other thread about this in the TNG forum.

I would love a new Trek show set after Nemesis.

Get some young stud to play a "cowboy in the captain's chair" like a Captain Mac Calhoun type of character. Lot's of super hot ladies. With a generous amount of guest appearances by the TNG crew and it would be a winner for me. :techman:

thumbtack September 13 2013 07:04 PM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Quote:

VOODOOXI wrote: (Post 8627515)
I agree with everything in the article...TNG back on tv is the only sure fire winner the franchise has to offer.

[COLOR=#bababa]http://www.rollingstone.com/movies/n...ation-20130910[/COLOR]
[COLOR=#bababa][/COLOR]

Bring Back Janeway!

Viper78 September 14 2013 12:16 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
I would go for a Titan series set around the time just after Nemesis. Dealing with the power struggle on Romulas with cameo appearances from the TNG cast.

R. Star September 14 2013 01:14 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Hard for there to be power struggles on Romulus when it blows up. ;)

jazamul September 14 2013 08:55 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
Quote:

thumbtack wrote: (Post 8640661)
Quote:

VOODOOXI wrote: (Post 8627515)
I agree with everything in the article...TNG back on tv is the only sure fire winner the franchise has to offer.

[COLOR=#bababa]http://www.rollingstone.com/movies/n...ation-20130910[/COLOR]
[COLOR=#bababa][/COLOR]

Bring Back Janeway!

Would never happen. Mulgrew has no interest in Janeway on TV again. She's also too old to carry the captains chair.

And as much as I love voyager, it was never successful enough to carry the Star Trek brand forward on TV.

We need something completely new.

Beyerstein September 14 2013 09:31 AM

Re: Rolling Stone Magazine makes a case for TNG to return to TV
 
People forget how popular TNG was. At its peak, it was going toe-to-toe with the most watched tv shows of its time


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.