The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek Movies I-X (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=42)
-   -   Your top 10 moments... (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=224926)

Smellmet September 5 2013 09:53 PM

Your top 10 moments...
 
What are everyone's top 10 scenes from the Trek Movies? (I'll include ST09 & STID if needed but as 10 of the 12 films for the majority I'll post it here) Here's mine:

1: Drydock flyby from TMP - the music alone carries the scene, the Enterprise has never looked better

2: Spocks Death in TWOK - nuff said

3: Scimitar battle in NEM - best space battle in the franchise, finally get to see what the Enterprise is capable of

4: Enterprise theft from TSFS - Fantastic scene, music, effects, suspense, humor, its got the lot

4: Enterprise launch in TMP - see number 1

5: Reliant 1st attack in TWOK - Brilliant music, suspense, great battle, and Kirk, despite getting caught with his pants down, back to his cunning best

6: Kelvin sequence in ST09 - Jaw dropping scene, birth of Kirk, top music

7: Opening sequence in STID - Cool as hell, Big E rising from the ocean, the volcanic ashes blending into the stars at the end, superb.

8: Borg space battle in FC - A bit cartoony now, but still one of my faves

9: USS Vengeance hunts down Enterprise in Warp in STID - The noise!

10: Phoenix launch in FC - Pivotal moment fantastic music

BillJ September 6 2013 01:01 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Quote:

Smellmet wrote: (Post 8603407)
9: USS Vengeance hunts down Enterprise in Warp in STID - The noise!

For ten, I'll have to think about it. But I absolutely loved this scene. I actually really like the Abramsverse warp effect, it gives you the feeling that warp speed can be a wild and dangerous ride. :techman:

Can't believe you left off the destruction of the Enterprise from The Search for Spock! :eek:

Melakon September 6 2013 01:22 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
The first one that immediately came to mind with the thread title was Chekov's "Botany Bay. Botany Bay. . .oh, no!" in The Wrath of Khan.

Smellmet September 6 2013 08:48 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Quote:

BillJ wrote: (Post 8604124)
Quote:

Smellmet wrote: (Post 8603407)
9: USS Vengeance hunts down Enterprise in Warp in STID - The noise!

For ten, I'll have to think about it. But I absolutely loved this scene. I actually really like the Abramsverse warp effect, it gives you the feeling that warp speed can be a wild and dangerous ride. :techman:

Can't believe you left off the destruction of the Enterprise from The Search for Spock! :eek:

Forgot about that - knew this would happen so keep 'em coming guys! I actually prefer the warp effect from 09, I like the warp 'tunnel' but I don't like the 'dust' the enterprise seems to leave behind - seems a bit cheesy - favourite warp effect is TMP or the first one from TWOK hands down

Smellmet September 6 2013 08:49 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Quote:

Melakon wrote: (Post 8604223)
The first one that immediately came to mind with the thread title was Chekov's "Botany Bay. Botany Bay. . .oh, no!" in The Wrath of Khan.

Great choice - mine seem to be big space scenes in the main, maybe I need to do a separate one for 'character' moments...

Mario de Monti September 6 2013 10:45 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Quote:

Smellmet wrote: (Post 8603407)
1: Drydock flyby from TMP - the music alone carries the scene, the Enterprise has never looked better

That is also my absolute number one, and not just in Trek but from all the movies I ever saw. I can just sit back and enjoy these six minutes of motion picture magic - I get goosebumps every time.

Other great moments from the Trek movies:
  • the battle in the Mutara Nebula in TWOK - the best staged and most believable Trek space battle ever
  • the first time we get to see the Excelsior in TSFS - a beautiful ship and the scene conveys a great sense of awe for the new design and technology (although Scotty clearly disagrees ;))
  • the campfire and "prison break" scenes from TFF - you´ll proabably hate me for this, but to me these scenes were among the only ones in all the movies that conveyed the sense of the triumvirate the way we had it in TOS
  • Scotty´s "Up your shaft!" to the turbolift in TSFS - just a great fun moment

Mario

Smellmet September 6 2013 11:07 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
^ I can see by your avatar!

I love the campfire scene in TFF, it's one of the best character moment in all the films, unfortunately for me though, its the only thing I like in the film. The drydock flyby though is just awesome, I just love the bit where Kirk is straining his neck to cop a look at the big E, then you can just see parts of it through the structure - brilliant, then when the shuttle swings round and Goldsmiths score bursts into life (the bit on your avatar) it's just timeless classic cinema, the likes of which you don't see any more

jpv2000 September 6 2013 06:25 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
1. Kirk being made Captain again at the end of ST IV. (I was cheering along with the crowd).

2. The fly over of Excelsior to reveal the 1701-A Enterprise with the crew then entering the bridge to hear the original bridge sounds. "My friends, we've come home." In the end of ST IV. (Whole scene was awesome for me. As I was absolutely positive Kirk would get the Excelsior until be big reveal).

3. TMP flyby. (Beautiful and long awaited return of my favorite ship).

4. The destruction of the Enterprise in ST III. (I said "My God" at the exact same moment as Kirk there. My wife whispered, "How did you know he was going to say that?" "I didn't." I told her with tears in my eyes. I actually didn't think they would do it).

5. Kirk falling upon hearing of David's death in ST III. (Another tear jerking moment for me, and I did not even like David, but I really felt Kirk's pain there).

6. Kirk's "I lost a brother once..." conversation with Spock at the end of ST V. (Very nicely done scene).

7. The wedding scene of "Nemesis" with Riker finally being made Captain and marrying Troi. (Longest overdue events in all of Trek for me).

8. The battle with Chang's ship at the end of ST VI. (The entire battle was breath taking for me. Sulu's "Shake her apart..." comment to the arrival of Excelsior and the death of Chang).

9. The dinner scene with the Klingons in ST VI. (When Chang said "We need breathing room.", Kirk's "Earth, Hitler, 1938." Classic Kirk moment here).

10. The Mutara Nebula battle in ST II. (My favorite space battle in Trek until the battle with Chang's ship).

Smellmet September 6 2013 07:33 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
^Cannot argue with any of those, all excellent ones, some that make me well up! Maybe I need to have a rethink!

davidant32 September 6 2013 07:58 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
I really liked when Scotty was trying to talk to the computer in TVH

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hShY6xZWVGE

Sometimes I like to reenact this to be goofy, then watch people's reactions

Smellmet September 6 2013 08:51 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Like it. That's up there with 'double dumb ass on you'

Mario de Monti September 6 2013 09:01 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Quote:

Smellmet wrote: (Post 8605585)
The drydock flyby though is just awesome, I just love the bit where Kirk is straining his neck to cop a look at the big E, then you can just see parts of it through the structure - brilliant, then when the shuttle swings round and Goldsmiths score bursts into life (the bit on your avatar) it's just timeless classic cinema, the likes of which you don't see any more

And to me, the final finishing touch to this already perfect scene is right at the end, when you look at the rear of the pod nearing the docking port and the little light over the doors comes on. Simply magical.

Quote:

jpv2000 wrote: (Post 8606920)
5. Kirk falling upon hearing of David's death in ST III. (Another tear jerking moment for me, and I did not even like David, but I really felt Kirk's pain there).

Absolutely! An amazing moment from Bill Shatner.

Quote:

davidant32 wrote: (Post 8607427)
I really liked when Scotty was trying to talk to the computer in TVH

Sometimes I like to reenact this to be goofy, then watch people's reactions

Don´t we all ;)

Gojira September 6 2013 09:22 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Here are mine in not particular order:

1. Kirk tells Dr. Gillian Taylor he is from the future. Star Trek IV
2. Examination of the Enterprise with Kirk & Scotty. TMP
3. Destruction of the Enterprise in Search for Spock
4. Destruction of the Enterprise-D in Generations.
5. Young Kirk meeting Old Spock. Trek09
6. Spock's arrival on the bridge of the Enterprise in TMP.
7. Spock's death in the Warth of Khan.
8. Sulu flips the guard in Search for Spock
9. Seeing the Excelsior for the first time in Search for Spock
10. Seeing the Enterprise rise out of the water in STiD.

Flying Spaghetti Monster September 6 2013 10:43 PM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
10: Spock mind-melds with a dying Pike.
This is how you write "new Trek." You give something new that we've never seen before out of something old. It doesn't reinvent the wheel and yet it is surprisingly poignant.

9. "Spock! It will work!" Kirk, in the Vulcan ship in '09. Really felt like Shatner, yet not. Showed the friendship between these two coming to it's own.

8. The hand phaser fight aboard the Narada. ('09) Certainly a great way to exercise the surround sound speakers. Loved the pinging sound effects. And the new "stun/kill" turning device is fantastically imaginative.

7. "Do you like Italian?" from TVH. Verbal ballet at it finest

6. "Call me Jim." GEN. Underrated moment.

5. "What is it with you, anyway." TUC. Love McCoy. Especially when he is used correctly.

4. "Turn death into a fighting chance to live." TSFS. McCoy again. Tied for this spot is his "I'd prefer a dose of common sense" line from TVH.

3. First Contact from First Contact. This is really powerful to me. Love every moment of this film, but the last moment is the best.

2. "Now, Mr. Spock" TWOK.
Before this, he was only Kirk in name, and he himself would admit that. He hadn't touched a captain's chair in a while, and even after taking command, he was simply running the usual gamut of standard orders anyone would give as he led the ship to Regula. But once he realized that Khan was back, and once he realized that he had only one way to get out of a bind, he became the Kirk we knew from TOS combined with someone much wiser. And it all happened in that moment.

1. "I never took the Kobyashi Maru Test, until now. What do you think of my solution...?" TWOK. Not just the most resonating scene in all the Trek films, but maybe in motion pictures in general.

jpv2000 September 7 2013 12:00 AM

Re: Your top 10 moments...
 
Quote:

Gojira wrote: (Post 8608045)
8. Sulu flips the guard in Search for Spock

Don't call him tiny. ;) Very cool Sulu moment.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:39 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.