The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Voyager (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=41)
-   -   The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?) (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=223057)

PopBoy August 18 2013 12:49 PM

The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Maybe I'm not thinking this through right/maybe it was covered in an episode (that i missed). But I always wondered why the crew couldn't program an medical team rather than just one hologram and enroll Kes & Mr.Paris. Couldn't they request another? Perhaps with less skills+experience but one that could easily handle itself just as well if not better than the pilot of the ship. Maybe a holographic nurse could've been whipped up especially in emergencies.

Ps i seem to recall the episode Latent Image when the doctor faced a massive ethical dilemma over which crewman to save...surely a med-bay with more holographic assistants would've resolved the docs issue.

Mage August 18 2013 12:53 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Voyager was very inconsistent in a lot of things. Early on, it was established that the complexity of a hologram like the Doctor was to difficult, and if they ever lost him, they'd be FUBAR'd. Then, later in season 4, there's an episode set several centuries later, where a back-up of the Doctor is found on an alien planet. Quite odd.

In season 5, they whip up a medical consultant for the Doctor, using information from the computer, who's a complete interactive hologram capable of making decisions on his own and the abality to perform complex surgical techniques.

So basicly, to answer your question..... there's no clear answer.

King Daniel Into Darkness August 18 2013 12:53 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
COPY C://NCC74656/LCARS/DAT/MEDBAY/EMH.EXE

INSUFFICIENT MEMORY TO PERFORM OPERATION. ABORT/RETRY/FAIL?





...oh wait, no. They made that Cardassian holodoc without much trouble. I got nuthin' :shrug:

teacake August 18 2013 12:57 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
The EMH probably made up bullshit reasons as to why it was impossible so he wouldn't have any rivals for his wonderfulness.

MacLeod August 18 2013 01:39 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Quote:

PopBoy wrote: (Post 8521702)
Maybe I'm not thinking this through right/maybe it was covered in an episode (that i missed). But I always wondered why the crew couldn't program an medical team rather than just one hologram and enroll Kes & Mr.Paris. Couldn't they request another? Perhaps with less skills+experience but one that could easily handle itself just as well if not better than the pilot of the ship. Maybe a holographic nurse could've been whipped up especially in emergencies.

Ps i seem to recall the episode Latent Image when the doctor faced a massive ethical dilemma over which crewman to save...surely a med-bay with more holographic assistants would've resolved the docs issue.

Or wait for it a stasis chamber which we know the ship has, and with only having one Doctor onboard and no nursing staff to speak about would make sense to have at least one availble at all times so you can freeze someone whilst working on another.

Sorry I think I was applying some logic, please forgive me. :p

PopBoy August 18 2013 02:27 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Quote:

MacLeod wrote: (Post 8521795)
Quote:

PopBoy wrote: (Post 8521702)
Maybe I'm not thinking this through right/maybe it was covered in an episode (that i missed). But I always wondered why the crew couldn't program an medical team rather than just one hologram and enroll Kes & Mr.Paris. Couldn't they request another? Perhaps with less skills+experience but one that could easily handle itself just as well if not better than the pilot of the ship. Maybe a holographic nurse could've been whipped up especially in emergencies.

Ps i seem to recall the episode Latent Image when the doctor faced a massive ethical dilemma over which crewman to save...surely a med-bay with more holographic assistants would've resolved the docs issue.

Or wait for it a stasis chamber which we know the ship has, and with only having one Doctor onboard and no nursing staff to speak about would make sense to have at least one availble at all times so you can freeze someone whilst working on another.

Sorry I think I was applying some logic, please forgive me. :p

Yes, Latent Image is an interesting episode don't get me wrong. But when you think about it - they could've (As you say) put one of the injured in stasis or have one or two holo-medical programes to assist in such scenarios.

NightJim August 18 2013 02:43 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Having just watched The Swarm last night, that episode at least hints that the program is massive and hugely complex and not for long term use. B'elanna did some jiggery pokery to keep it stable that failed after two years. I'd imagine if you start adding extra programs to that

Thinking about it, the episode makes it quite clear that the fix for the EMH they do is temporary at best, and likely to fail further down the line.

My question is, why doesn't someone develop one for Engineering, an EEH if you like (which you probably don't)? Imagine all the problem in there that go wrong that's too dangerous when everyone has to abandon the place. Having someone who can stay there and keep working would be a hell of boon, way more than an extra pair of hands the EMH was designed to be.

MacLeod August 18 2013 02:47 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Quote:

PopBoy wrote: (Post 8521891)
Quote:

MacLeod wrote: (Post 8521795)
Quote:

PopBoy wrote: (Post 8521702)
Maybe I'm not thinking this through right/maybe it was covered in an episode (that i missed). But I always wondered why the crew couldn't program an medical team rather than just one hologram and enroll Kes & Mr.Paris. Couldn't they request another? Perhaps with less skills+experience but one that could easily handle itself just as well if not better than the pilot of the ship. Maybe a holographic nurse could've been whipped up especially in emergencies.

Ps i seem to recall the episode Latent Image when the doctor faced a massive ethical dilemma over which crewman to save...surely a med-bay with more holographic assistants would've resolved the docs issue.

Or wait for it a stasis chamber which we know the ship has, and with only having one Doctor onboard and no nursing staff to speak about would make sense to have at least one availble at all times so you can freeze someone whilst working on another.

Sorry I think I was applying some logic, please forgive me. :p

Yes, Latent Image is an interesting episode don't get me wrong. But when you think about it - they could've (As you say) put one of the injured in stasis or have one or two holo-medical programes to assist in such scenarios.

But even with it's flaws in logic, it was still one of VOY's better episodes.

PopBoy August 18 2013 02:54 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Yes i agree. I said that. Its a really good episode. But it did make me think about the crew not coming up with a holo-nurse or two.

captainkirk August 18 2013 04:08 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Quote:

NightJim wrote: (Post 8521918)
My question is, why doesn't someone develop one for Engineering, an EEH if you like (which you probably don't)? Imagine all the problem in there that go wrong that's too dangerous when everyone has to abandon the place. Having someone who can stay there and keep working would be a hell of boon, way more than an extra pair of hands the EMH was designed to be.

I think Kirk would have found that very useful.

NightJim August 18 2013 09:17 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
My immediate reaction was that you were making a joke about an extra pair of hands. Then I realised what you actually meant.

Yes, let's call that exhibit one for why it's a good idea.

PopBoy August 18 2013 09:35 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
hahahha! Yeah, basically....my point is how you've described it. An extra pair of hands would've been reaaaaally useful!

Melakon August 18 2013 09:37 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
Quote:

NightJim wrote: (Post 8521918)
. . .My question is, why doesn't someone develop one for Engineering, an EEH if you like (which you probably don't)? Imagine all the problem in there that go wrong that's too dangerous when everyone has to abandon the place. Having someone who can stay there and keep working would be a hell of boon, way more than an extra pair of hands the EMH was designed to be.

This sort of happens with Leland Orser's character of Dejaren in "Revulsion". He's a maintenance hologram, but poorly treated by his crewmates and becomes a psychopath.

LobsterAfternoon August 18 2013 09:45 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
I reckon the nature of emergency engineering problems sorta makes a hologram a really bad choice as a helper. Power fluctuations could make the hologram appear/disappear. Imagine having a holographic engineer who shorts out and drops a plasma torch in a warp core or something.

C.E. Evans August 18 2013 10:43 PM

Re: The Doctor (why didn't they just make more?)
 
To me, the EMH was never meant for long-time usage--about 63 days maximum of continuous operation, IIRC--and under ideal circumstances, would never be used at all.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.