The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Trek Tech (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   A thought about Romulan warp drive... (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=216019)

Tiberius June 7 2013 05:27 AM

A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Given that the Romulans are an offshoot from the Vulcans, and also given that the Vulcans use rings as their warp nacelles, could this explain the double-wing design of the Romulan warbird?

http://25.media.tumblr.com/2992a37cf...w1fo1_1280.jpg

If the top and bottom of the wing make a ring, could this be the warp nacelle?

The inhabited parts of the ship could be the beak at the front, the horseshoe at the back and the connecting structure that goes between. The entire wing, top and bottom, could be the wrap-around warp nacelle. The actual pods at the wing tips could be a part of the warp system, or maybe just the impulse engines.

Thoughts?

T'Girl June 7 2013 10:31 PM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
It's an interesting idea. Instead of a perfectly circular ring, a somewhat swashed oval.

:)

C.E. Evans June 8 2013 12:36 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Personally, I've viewed the dual-hull design of the D'deridex-class warbird to be influenced more by politics than by any propulsion system. I think the Romulans wanted to build the biggest and most intimidating starship they could and chose a design that was huge in the sense that it had an enormous length, beam, and draft, but due largely to a giant hole in the center.

Avro Arrow June 8 2013 05:16 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
It strikes me as kind of unlikely, since it's the only Romulan ship we've seen with that kind of structure in 200 years of history. As well, the pods on the wing tips look pretty much identical to the pods on the Romulan science ship and scout ship from the same period... and those must be stand-alone warp nacelles, since neither of them have a ring.

But I guess anything's possible! :) Maybe they decided to use a warp ring for nostalgia or something, and it didn't work out well, so they didn't design any more ships with them. Or perhaps since the D'deridex is so incredibly large, a ring is the only way to generate a sufficiently large warp field, and the other ships don't have rings because they're smaller and don't need them?

Maurice June 8 2013 08:39 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Only if you ignore the designer's intent.

T'Girl June 8 2013 10:23 PM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Quote:

Maurice wrote: (Post 8218774)
Only if you ignore the designer's intent.

The same "designer's intend' that resulted in the D'deridex not being given any impulse engines?

:)

Manticore June 8 2013 11:34 PM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
I prefer to think of it as the natural extension of the D7s that the Romulans got in the 23rd century. If you think about it, modern Romulan ships have more in common with them than with the old-style "flying saucers" that they used to fly.

I also like to think that the hole is where the singularity is.

DonIago June 9 2013 12:10 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
I once read something that speculated that the odd design was so that there could at times be cloaked ships within the gaps.

Tiberius June 9 2013 05:35 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Quote:

Avro Arrow wrote: (Post 8218546)
It strikes me as kind of unlikely, since it's the only Romulan ship we've seen with that kind of structure in 200 years of history.

Actually, the scoutship/science ship had upper and lower wings as well:

http://www.lightningcoyote.com/old%2.../Ships/rl1.jpg

Avro Arrow June 9 2013 06:03 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
^ Hmmn... where'd that ortho come from? It doesn't look particularly accurate compared to this screen capture from Memory Alpha. There it looks like the front of the "wings" just have some kind of panels, just coloured dark. And the image I linked to doesn't have those yellow glowy bits at all.

I don't think I can directly link to images on Ex Astris Scientia, but on this page, if you look at the image labelled "Romulan science ship - details", the bottom-left image shows that there's no space between the top and bottom of the wing structure on the science ship version either.

zDarby June 9 2013 07:39 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
To give the scale of the volume between the wings, you could handily fit three Ent-Bs in there.
Hell!! You could fit an Ambassador in there but you'd never get her out again. :rommie:
But the refit Excelsiors could enter & exit easily, as long as the one amidships waited her turn.
This, by the way, is with a length of 1041 meters, not the 1200 m sometimes quoted.

Edit: Indeed, a Galaxy class could fit within the wings. It'd be a very tight fit and you'd need to cut her out, but she'd fit. Though a Galaxy-X would not...Unless the D'deridex were 1200 meters long.
Two New Orleans classes would fit, or two Springfields. (Wolf 359 vessels)
Much more interesting (to me) is that two McKinley stations would fit handily as well, if their arms were folded up. Indeed, if you were careful about how you stacked them, you might get away with four: two to starboard, two to port.
Indeed, if either top or bottom wing unlocked and hinged, you could tote some serious hardware in there, installing it ready-to-go.
With tractor beams holding your cargo from all sides, it's not going anywhere until it's time to deploy.
That would make a seriously capable and formidable beast.

Tiberius June 9 2013 07:42 AM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Quote:

Avro Arrow wrote: (Post 8221825)
^ Hmmn... where'd that ortho come from? It doesn't look particularly accurate compared to this screen capture from Memory Alpha. There it looks like the front of the "wings" just have some kind of panels, just coloured dark. And the image I linked to doesn't have those yellow glowy bits at all.

I don't think I can directly link to images on Ex Astris Scientia, but on this page, if you look at the image labelled "Romulan science ship - details", the bottom-left image shows that there's no space between the top and bottom of the wing structure on the science ship version either.

Hmm, I found the version I posted in just a quick google search, and I thought it was accurate. Might have been for one of the computer games maybe? In any case, you are right.

Perhaps the on screen version has the upper and lower wings, and they just put the impulse engines in between, which is why it looks solid. :p

Timo June 9 2013 11:00 PM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Quote:

Personally, I've viewed the dual-hull design of the D'deridex-class warbird to be influenced more by politics than by any propulsion system. I think the Romulans wanted to build the biggest and most intimidating starship they could and chose a design that was huge in the sense that it had an enormous length, beam, and draft, but due largely to a giant hole in the center.
Actually, when you think it through, the Romulans made much more efficient use of space than the Feds. Had they left the upper or lower "wing" out of their design, the ship would have looked much like an average Federation or perhaps Klingon warship; now there is much more useful volume in the ship for the given outer dimensions.

Timo Saloniemi

Tiberius June 9 2013 11:38 PM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Quote:

Timo wrote: (Post 8224201)
Quote:

Personally, I've viewed the dual-hull design of the D'deridex-class warbird to be influenced more by politics than by any propulsion system. I think the Romulans wanted to build the biggest and most intimidating starship they could and chose a design that was huge in the sense that it had an enormous length, beam, and draft, but due largely to a giant hole in the center.
Actually, when you think it through, the Romulans made much more efficient use of space than the Feds. Had they left the upper or lower "wing" out of their design, the ship would have looked much like an average Federation or perhaps Klingon warship; now there is much more useful volume in the ship for the given outer dimensions.

Timo Saloniemi

I don't get this.

If they had filled in the space between the wings, they'd had massively increased the amount of space available, and yet not increased the vessel's dimensions. When you have carved out the entire center of your ship, I don't think it's very efficient at all. Federation and Klingon ships at least don't carve big holes through the center of their ships.

Also, given that the only parts of the waarbird that we ever saw with windows are the beak and the horseshoe at the back, it looks like only a fairly small part of the warbird is actually habitable.

Timo June 10 2013 07:58 PM

Re: A thought about Romulan warp drive...
 
Quote:

Federation and Klingon ships at least don't carve big holes through the center of their ships.
But they do! That's the thing you easily miss if you don't think it through... An empty, wasteful space is an empty, wasteful space even when it isn't surrounded by structures from all directions.

There is a whopping big empty space between the nacelles of every one of the Enterprises, just like there is one between the nacelles of the Romulan ship. But the Feds don't even put a ski-box on top of that space, so they use the volume much less efficiently than the Romulans.

There are select few Federation ships that don't carve this giant cavity in between the nacelles; the Nebula class is one of the very few major designs not to have this feature. But funnily enough, every Romulan design other than the D'deridex places hull elements directly between the nacelles: the old Bird of Prey (or whatever), the scoutcraft, the science vessel and even Senator Vreenak's yacht all have the nacelles flanking the hull, rather than a cavity.

Quote:

Also, given that the only parts of the waarbird that we ever saw with windows are the beak and the horseshoe at the back, it looks like only a fairly small part of the warbird is actually habitable.
By that token, Kirk's TOS ship did not have any crew facilities in the saucer section...

Timo Saloniemi


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:42 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.