The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   General Trek Discussion (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   Hirogen vs Dominion? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=215503)

bbjeg June 2 2013 10:12 PM

Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
The Dominion have power and numbers but the Hirogen are formidable to species 8472 and I haven't seen a Hirogen Borg even though they're close to each other. Who would win in an all out war?

Lt. Cheka Wey June 2 2013 10:18 PM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Dominion, they seem much bigger.

bbjeg June 3 2013 04:09 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
On second thought, even though I think the Hirogens "hunter way" was way underused, the dominion will probably win. The ultimate hunters vs the ultimate predators like the Dominion with numbers backing it would be a overwhelming fight for the Hirogen.

JirinPanthosa June 3 2013 04:17 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
We never got any clear indication in Voyager how big the Hirogen really are.

But, they did appear both in season 4 and season 7, at points in space 30000 light years away from each other. And it's implied they controlled most of that giant communication network that Voyager blew up in season 4. They are a more powerful race than is ever stated directly in Voyager.

Against the full force of the Dominion fleet the Dominion probably wins, but assuming they wouldn't be able to send their entire fleet to the Hirogen front, I think the Hirogen would win. Also the great link would be a lot more vulnerable to them than the Cardassians and Romulans.

bbjeg June 3 2013 05:05 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
After digging out my Star Trek Star Chart Atlas (It was only packed away because I'm still unpacking) Dominion space is about 15,000 light years long verses the Hirogen 30,000 light year network. Hirogen space is 2x bigger.

R. Star June 3 2013 05:23 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Controlling an interstellar empire that spans 15,000 light years and an essentially nomadic hunting culture spread out across 30,000 light years are two very different things.

teacake June 3 2013 05:29 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Dominion, no contest.

Vulcan Logician June 3 2013 05:34 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Apples and oranges. Hirogen are hunters. They would want to "bag a founder" as their ultimate trophy. The dominion would be more focused on conquering the Hirogen. So easily the Dominion would win; they are more organized.

teacake June 3 2013 05:38 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
But the real challenge would be nailing that founder to the wall.

Mr. Laser Beam June 3 2013 05:43 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Hirogen would lose on numbers alone. They only travel in small groups. The Dominion send thousands of Jem'Hadar out at any given time.

bbjeg June 3 2013 07:09 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
The more I think about it, the more I think the Hirogen won't be so easily defeated. The Dominion fall to federation weapons while the Hirogen negates species 8472's powerful biogenic energy weapon, which was capable of shattering a borg cube. Their armor must be strong.

Quote:

Vulcan Logician wrote: (Post 8194519)
The dominion would be more focused on conquering the Hirogen.

That's the thing, the Hirogen have no planet, so the Jem'Hadar would have to spread thin across Hirogen space to conquer them.

Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 8194549)
The Dominion send thousands of Jem'Hadar out at any given time.

If the Hirogen hull is as strong as I think it is, it'll be like a thousand Antelope verses a pack of lions.

Vulcan Logician June 3 2013 07:20 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Quote:

teacake wrote: (Post 8194534)
But the real challenge would be nailing that founder to the wall.

What? You can't nail a bucket to the wall?

bbjeg June 3 2013 07:21 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Also, the Hirogen warships are equipped with monotanium armor plating, which have the added effect of scattering targeting beams. (VOY: "Hunters") They may be able to hide from the Dominion.

R. Star June 3 2013 07:25 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
That's really a simplified explanation. The Federation didn't cause the Dominion to "fall" all they really did was check their invasion of the Alpha Quadrant, and only managed to do that because the chokepoint that was the wormhole was so often closed that they couldn't bring their full forces to bear.

That one 8472 the Hirogen hunted was described as being wounded even before the hunt started. So isolating one wounded 8472 is not the equivalent of saying Hirogen weaponry can unequivocally defeat them. Being Voyager beat the Hirogen on a number of fights, that would argue against super armor and more for cunning on the part of the Hirogen.

Furthermore the Dominion's polaron weaponry did cut through the shields of the Federation when they first encountered them. It took the Federation years to counter that, Weyoun being surprised when the shields of DS9 held out against their opening barrage. So, it's just as likely those polaron beams would chew up the Hirogen until they adapt as it were. As for their stealth mode? The Dominion detected the Defiant's cloak rather easily with an anti-proton beam. Seems the same concept.

But all that aside, it does come done to numbers. The Dominion regularly fielded fleets of thousands of ships and can build the quickly and breed crews for them even more quickly. An unusually large Hirogen group was a few dozen ships. And given the way they interact with each other, each individual hunter trying to be the alpha, they aren't team players at all.

Vulcan Logician June 3 2013 08:00 AM

Re: Hirogen vs Dominion?
 
Yes, R Star. It is obvious the Dominion would win. Look at it like this: in terms of motivation. The police (Dominion) exist in an organized set of units, all with a singular goal: to espouse its own order. The police are trying to arrest a serial killer (hirogen) who has caused fear in the neighborhood, but does not RULE the neighborhood. A serial killer may evade the police, but a serial killer will never destroy the entire police force. The police are too organized. They are a collective unit. Having a home planet has its advantages.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.