The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   TV & Media (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=28)
-   -   An Elementary theory (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=212341)

Joe Washington May 10 2013 07:08 PM

An Elementary theory
 
BEWARE OF SOME BRIEF SPOILERS

As the countdown to the Elementary season finale begins, I've come up with a theory concerning Irene Adler and Moriarty that sets up a radical direction for the show:

I believe Irene Adler and Moriarty are one and the same.

I think Moriarty is an alias Irene used to commit her crimes through her operatives. She created the Moriarty alias not only to cover up her true identity but to fool others into thinking she is a he.

Irene got involved with Sherlock initially to get to know the man who has been poking his nose into some of her crimes and then to remove him as a threat to her plans. But the more she got to know Holmes, the more she was less inclined to kill him which is why she told one of her assassins to forget about the plan to kill Holmes and make his death look like an accidental overdose.

However, Irene knew that this relationship with Holmes couldn't last forever, him being a criminal investigator and her being a criminal mastermind. There's no future in them being together so Irene faked her death and made it look like her alter ego killed her. Over the years, Irene has been keeping an eye on Holmes, him being her greatest object of curiosity.

I think once Holmes finds out all of this, it will push him over the edge into a relapse.

If my theory is correct, this revelation will make the Holmes-Adler relationship more complicated and twisted than the original Holmes-Adler relationship.

Christopher May 10 2013 07:20 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
^I've suspected the same thing for a while now. The other popular theory I've heard is that Moriarty is Holmes's father.

Greg Cox May 10 2013 08:05 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
I don't know. I'm suspicious of that character played by F. Murray Abraham a few weeks ago. Why would you cast a big name, Oscar-winning actor just to play one of Moriarity's minions?

F. Murray Abraham as Moriarity makes sense. As one of his flunkies . . . not so much.

Christopher May 10 2013 10:01 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
^A red herring, maybe? They cast big-name actors as his minions to make us think "Oh, this must be the real Moriarty," and then they surprise us by revealing the web is even bigger. Sort of a subversion of the TV-mystery cliche of having the biggest actor always be the murderer.

Greg Cox May 11 2013 12:29 AM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Quote:

Christopher wrote: (Post 8069902)
^A red herring, maybe? They cast big-name actors as his minions to make us think "Oh, this must be the real Moriarty," and then they surprise us by revealing the web is even bigger. Sort of a subversion of the TV-mystery cliche of having the biggest actor always be the murderer.

That would be ingenious . . . .

sojourner May 11 2013 01:38 AM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Irene is a good suspect for Moriarty, I was thinking the same thing after the latest episode.
What about Captain Gregson? Remember he was also in London for a period of time and only recently returned to New York, mirroring Moriarty's activity.

Gov Kodos May 11 2013 01:47 AM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Quote:

sojourner wrote: (Post 8070616)
Irene is a good suspect for Moriarty, I was thinking the same thing after the latest episode.
What about Captain Gregson? Remember he was also in London for a period of time and only recently returned to New York, mirroring Moriarty's activity.

That's a thought about Irene. I wouldn't be surprised to learn she thought Holmes was dead, or was targeted by Moriarty, and faked her death to protect Holmes, whether on her own or at the urging of Moriarty. Gregson, could be, I think his offering Watson a job as a sober companion is a red herring to get the audience to think there could be a connection. My money is on Mrs Hudson as Moriarty. Or Joan, herself, that would be unexpected.

stj May 11 2013 12:31 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
To me it seems rather tiny for Moriarty to be one of the few continuing characters we've seen. It's true that television strongly favors personal viewpoints, and for most people the emotionally significant parts of life center on a rather small number of characters. But there really is an appeal to drma that is set in a larger world. However flambuoyant the enlarged characters, however convoluted their recomplicated interrelationships, there is still a flavor of narccissism that can make such typical ("make it personl" is the hack's cliche) offerings not just monotonous, but distasteful.

Also, odd as it may seem, I thought that Sherlock was imagining/hallucinating Adler's appearance, that Watson did not see her and was alarmed at Holmes' reaction. It is entirely possible for someone to see a dead loved one without being psychotic. As in so much, there is a continuum between normal consciousness and full blown psychosis.

lurok May 15 2013 07:43 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
I got confused when saw F. Murray, as thought he was same spook character he plays in Homeland. :)

Dormer as Adler seems a bit of a waste unless they do something interesting with character; but guess we'll have to wait and see.

On Holmes psychosis front, I assume some writers have explored options of Moriarty as alter-ego manifestation?

Gov Kodos May 15 2013 09:13 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Quote:

lurok wrote: (Post 8092744)

On Holmes psychosis front, I assume some writers have explored options of Moriarty as alter-ego manifestation?

'The Seven-Per-Cent Solution' is one story along the lines of Moriarty and Holmes along those lines.

Allyn Gibson May 16 2013 12:40 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Quote:

Gov Kodos wrote: (Post 8093305)
Quote:

lurok wrote: (Post 8092744)

On Holmes psychosis front, I assume some writers have explored options of Moriarty as alter-ego manifestation?

'The Seven-Per-Cent Solution' is one story along the lines of Moriarty and Holmes along those lines.

Also, Michael Dibdin's The Last Sherlock Holmes Story.

Guy Gardener May 16 2013 03:52 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
I remember Andy Grffith convincing me on an episode of Married with Children that Andy Griffith is the last person in the universe anyone would suspect of being a serial killer.

ManOnTheWave May 16 2013 05:09 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Personally, I've been hoping Moriarty would turn out to be Mycroft, who I don't think has ever been mentioned in this series and may not even exist.

Christopher May 16 2013 07:49 PM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Quote:

ManOnTheWave wrote: (Post 8097409)
Personally, I've been hoping Moriarty would turn out to be Mycroft, who I don't think has ever been mentioned in this series and may not even exist.

We've seen that Holmes's father has the first initial M. I've been assuming that Mycroft has been changed from his brother to his father for this version.

Joe Washington May 17 2013 03:00 AM

Re: An Elementary theory
 
Tonight's episode of Elementary just proved me right. :)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:40 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.