The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek Movies I-X (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=42)
-   -   If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP... (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=211843)

gastrof May 6 2013 10:29 PM

If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
Would you warn them that V'ger was going to take Ilia?

(I got a copy of the "special longer version" in the mail today, and have it running as I type. And yeah, I'm especially enjoying it. Been a long time.)

C.E. Evans May 7 2013 01:02 AM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
The refit occurred before Ilia was taken and before V'Ger arrived. How could anyone warn anyone of that?
:confused:

Melakon May 7 2013 02:15 AM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
Quote:

C.E. Evans wrote: (Post 8051848)
How could anyone warn anyone of that?
:confused:

Yeah. This is a situation like all those Twilight Zone style episodes trying to warn everyone the night Lincoln gets shot. You'd either be locked up as a lunatic, or arrested as a conspirator.

Or you somehow wind up shooting him yourself.

gastrof May 7 2013 06:13 AM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
Quote:

C.E. Evans wrote: (Post 8051848)
The refit occurred before Ilia was taken and before V'Ger arrived. How could anyone warn anyone of that?
:confused:

You're right. The refit took place before the V'Ger incident and before Ilia's being taken.

That's why I said you'd be on the Refitrpise. See how that all fits together?

Now...I'll go slowly...listen carefully...

The question was if YOU found yourself ON THE REFITPRISE DURING TMP...

That's right...YOU. On...come on...you can do it...on the refit Enterprise during the period/events of TMP...

YOU...uh huh...YOU...would YOU warn them, knowing as you do what's coming, that V'ger was going to take Ilia?

Would you make the effort? If so, why? If not, why? If so, how? Who? When?

See how all this works? It's a kind of game, a thinking game, and to play it you have to pay attention and get the question/situation that's presented...and most of all...you have to think.

Come on, dude. I mean, really. It wasn't that hard an OP to pick up on. Did you really need it to be spelled out like this, or are you just giving me/us a hard time?

Melakon May 7 2013 06:27 AM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
Disregarding insulting a commenter's intelligence, how do you gain the information that Ilia is going to be killed?

You: Captain! V'ger's going to digitize Lieutenant Ilia!
Kirk: Who are you? How did you get on my ship? Where did you get this information?
You: I already watched the movie!
Kirk: Security!

R. Star May 7 2013 07:03 AM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
Quote:

gastrof wrote: (Post 8052973)
Quote:

C.E. Evans wrote: (Post 8051848)
The refit occurred before Ilia was taken and before V'Ger arrived. How could anyone warn anyone of that?
:confused:

You're right. The refit took place before the V'Ger incident and before Ilia's being taken.

That's why I said you'd be on the Refitrpise. See how that all fits together?

Now...I'll go slowly...listen carefully...

The question was if YOU found yourself ON THE REFITPRISE DURING TMP...

That's right...YOU. On...come on...you can do it...on the refit Enterprise during the period/events of TMP...

YOU...uh huh...YOU...would YOU warn them, knowing as you do what's coming, that V'ger was going to take Ilia?

Would you make the effort? If so, why? If not, why? If so, how? Who? When?

See how all this works? It's a kind of game, a thinking game, and to play it you have to pay attention and get the question/situation that's presented...and most of all...you have to think.

Come on, dude. I mean, really. It wasn't that hard an OP to pick up on. Did you really need it to be spelled out like this, or are you just giving me/us a hard time?

Real classy. Perhaps you would like to kick a puppy while you're at it? :rolleyes:

Timelord Victorious May 7 2013 12:55 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
Easy. Make small claim after claim to prove yourself.
Don't start with Ilia.

Tell them right before they encounter it what kind of power output the cloud represents.
Give Spock the hint to look for radio signals.
Tell them to answer it BEFORE Ilia gets digitized.
Tell them to communicate to V'ger about knowing the creator before everything almost goes south.
Get inside and transmit the final sequence.

if that fails, tell V'ger to assimilate Ilia and mate with Decker, as that was the only thing that satisfied V'ger anyway and tell Kirk, "Sorry, shit happens":p

xvicente May 7 2013 01:34 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
I can't think of nothing that could save Ilia. She was zapped when the plasma probe came to examine the bridge and no one could prevent that.

The fact Spock smashed the keyboard (thus logically disabling the entire computer system :lol:) and got a quick shock therapy might have something to do with the zapping, -- or not.

After that point I could tell "V'Ger is Voyager 6" and maybe shorten the movie. But then again, that could cause Vger to zap the Enterprise and Earth. Not good.

Then the problem of convince someone I'm form the past but know the future. It could cause the abramsverse to form even weirder.

What I probably would end doing is call Ilia and say "Hey hottie, you'll die tomorrow. Wanna have snu-snu for the last time?"

C.E. Evans May 7 2013 02:33 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
Quote:

gastrof wrote: (Post 8052973)
Quote:

C.E. Evans wrote: (Post 8051848)
The refit occurred before Ilia was taken and before V'Ger arrived. How could anyone warn anyone of that?
:confused:

You're right. The refit took place before the V'Ger incident and before Ilia's being taken.

That's why I said you'd be on the Refitrpise. See how that all fits together?

Now...I'll go slowly...listen carefully...

The question was if YOU found yourself ON THE REFITPRISE DURING TMP...

That's right...YOU. On...come on...you can do it...on the refit Enterprise during the period/events of TMP...

YOU...uh huh...YOU...would YOU warn them, knowing as you do what's coming, that V'ger was going to take Ilia?

Would you make the effort? If so, why? If not, why? If so, how? Who? When?

See how all this works? It's a kind of game, a thinking game, and to play it you have to pay attention and get the question/situation that's presented...and most of all...you have to think.

Come on, dude. I mean, really. It wasn't that hard an OP to pick up on. Did you really need it to be spelled out like this, or are you just giving me/us a hard time?

Wow, somebody needs to get out of their house more.
:rolleyes:

I can't help that you came up with a rather flawed idea. Don't get all mad and pissy at me for that.

EDIT: Hell, my question still stands, "How can anyone on the refit Enterprise know in advance that Ilia was going to be kidnapped by V'Ger?" They didn't even know who the hell V'Ger was or what it wanted. Now you think about that.

marksound May 7 2013 03:20 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
Here's the scenario ...

"Lightning storm in space??? I gotta get to the bridge!"
"Slow down! Let me give you this shot!"
"THTOPPIT!"
"You got numb tongue? I can fix that."
"OW! THTOPPIT!"

Something like that. :lol:

C.E. Evans May 7 2013 03:22 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
^^^
I guess that's the only true answer to this thread.
:rommie:

Peach Wookiee May 7 2013 06:19 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
Quote:

gastrof wrote: (Post 8052973)
Quote:

C.E. Evans wrote: (Post 8051848)
The refit occurred before Ilia was taken and before V'Ger arrived. How could anyone warn anyone of that?
:confused:

You're right. The refit took place before the V'Ger incident and before Ilia's being taken.

That's why I said you'd be on the Refitrpise. See how that all fits together?

Now...I'll go slowly...listen carefully...

The question was if YOU found yourself ON THE REFITPRISE DURING TMP...

That's right...YOU. On...come on...you can do it...on the refit Enterprise during the period/events of TMP...

YOU...uh huh...YOU...would YOU warn them, knowing as you do what's coming, that V'ger was going to take Ilia?

Would you make the effort? If so, why? If not, why? If so, how? Who? When?

See how all this works? It's a kind of game, a thinking game, and to play it you have to pay attention and get the question/situation that's presented...and most of all...you have to think.

Come on, dude. I mean, really. It wasn't that hard an OP to pick up on. Did you really need it to be spelled out like this, or are you just giving me/us a hard time?

gastrof, we don't insult people's intelligence like that here. And we don't try to lure someone into a fight. Infraction for trolling, comments to PM, please.

Galileo7 May 7 2013 10:27 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
Quote:

gastrof wrote: (Post 8051260)
Would you warn them that V'ger was going to take Ilia?

Yes, however security would probably escort me to the brig.:vulcan:

R. Star May 7 2013 10:31 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Refitprise during TMP...
 
Let's think cause and effect for a moment. Let's suppose you somehow are on the Enterprise with foreknowledge of what will happen. Let's say you even manage to persuade Kirk of this. So Kirk does something to prevent Ilia from getting beamed away.

Did anyone stop and wonder what happens then? V'ger doesn't have their mouthpiece on the Enterprise to negotiate with. It's very possible they decide a ship full of "carbon units" is more trouble than it's worth and just purge it. Especially after they terminated their means of contacting them by stopping them from absorbing Ilia.

So by saving Ilia, you don't save her for long, and you doom the whole planet Earth. Congratulations. :)

C.E. Evans May 7 2013 11:24 PM

Re: If you found yourself aboard the Enterprise during TMP...
 
You wind up making the situation worse, even with divine knowledge of the future.
:shifty:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.