The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek Movies XI+ (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=50)
-   -   Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=210370)

Shaka Zulu April 23 2013 11:19 PM

Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here's How to Do It: One Trekkie’s Proposal

Basically put, the author wants a gay character in the next Star Trek movie, or for Mr. Sulu to come out (or even Chekov or Scott.)

Personally, although I think that the franchise needs GLBT characters, I don't think that this movie and the next one are the best places to do it; only a TV show can pull that off and have the time to do it well enough. I also think that the writer is putting way too much on the shoulders of the production team to accomplish this, simply because it's a possibly blockbuster movie based on a popular franchise.

But that's just me; does anybody else have any thoughts about this?

Mr. Laser Beam April 23 2013 11:23 PM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Well, if you believe the novels, there's already been at least one gay character (Lt. Hawk from ST:FC).

As for how to introduce one onscreen: Just a throwaway line and that's it. Why get more complicated than it needs to be?

BillJ April 23 2013 11:30 PM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
I've never cared one way or the other.

bullethead April 23 2013 11:33 PM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Here's how I would do it in a series:
-Introduce one main/recurring character and do not show his/her sexuality. Focus on establishing the character's personality and competence.
-In the second season, casually mention and show that the character is in a homosexual relationship with a minor character.
-Season 3 is the earliest point the marriage should happen and it should be a mundane affair.

Also, have gay couples in the backgrounds of scenes, like TOS did with people of color back in the day. Shoving the "accept gay/lesbian/whatever" message into people's face is more likely to backfire than change people's preconceptions.

feek61 April 23 2013 11:34 PM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Really, why even make a distinction? Can't they all be Starfleet members? I agree in the film franchise it may be too contrived feeling. A series is a different story.

R. Star April 23 2013 11:37 PM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
If you're going to do that, have an actual character arc beyond "we have a token gay guy to show how politically correct we are." Otherwise it really doesn't contribute anything.

StarMan April 24 2013 12:03 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
I wonder if people think that because society has progressed it shouldn't be a big deal. But, that's just it. It's not a big deal anymore. That boat sailed long ago. They ought to have taken a crack at it in the early 90's when the issue was more contentious. Fortunately, society has evolved (notwithstanding the bigots tagging behind, of course). Unfortunately for Trek, it didn't take advantage when it was more relevant. Now, inserting a gay character simply because it hasn't previously would seem awfully tacky.

cbspock April 24 2013 03:13 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
What does it matter. So tired of this nonsense, it doesn't contribute to anything in a movie.


-Chris

Shaka Zulu April 24 2013 03:15 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Quote:

bullethead wrote: (Post 7991605)
Here's how I would do it in a series:
-Introduce one main/recurring character and do not show his/her sexuality. Focus on establishing the character's personality and competence.
-In the second season, casually mention and show that the character is in a homosexual relationship with a minor character.
-Season 3 is the earliest point the marriage should happen and it should be a mundane affair.

Also, have gay couples in the backgrounds of scenes, like TOS did with people of color back in the day. Shoving the "accept gay/lesbian/whatever" message into people's face is more likely to backfire than change people's preconceptions.

I like the first couple of points, but the last one ('Shoving the "accept gay/lesbian/whatever" message into people's face is more likely to backfire than change people's preconceptions') is wrong. GLBT people aren't doing that, they just want what they are as people to be normal without others objecting to it.

T J April 24 2013 03:16 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Quote:

BillJ wrote: (Post 7991575)
I've never cared one way or the other.

THIS! :rolleyes:

Admiral Buzzkill April 24 2013 03:23 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Every other tv series and movie in the world manages to have gay characters now without it being complicated or a debate. This makes Star Trek creatively backward and inferior to the rest of the business, in at least this one regard.

Give Chekov a boyfriend and be done with it.

sttngfan1701d April 24 2013 03:26 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Well, it comes off as silly on Doctor Who when they reference it in one-liners. There's already an openly gay actor playing Spock. Do they "need" to specifically reference gay characters on screen? It all depends on how it's handled I guess. Show a guy at a bar openly flirting with men/aliens/what-have you Captain Jack style like Kirk brazenly flirting with Uhura in the first film. It would be funny if handled right.

Admiral Buzzkill April 24 2013 03:32 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Quote:

sttngfan1701d wrote: (Post 7992667)
Well, it comes off as silly on Doctor Who when they reference it in one-liners.

No, it doesn't, except when they're being deliberately funny.

I'm sorry, do some fans even watch other movies and TV? Why is this so difficult and mysterious?

J. Allen April 24 2013 03:35 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
Statistically speaking, Star Trek already has a number of gay characters. They're various members of the Enterprise crew, citizens of Earth, Vulcan, Romulus, and so on, and they serve in other areas of the Federation. You just don't know it because simply being gay isn't automatically some kind of openly telegraphed behavior, but they're there.

Maurice April 24 2013 04:06 AM

Re: Star Trek Needs a Gay Character and Here’s How to Do It
 
I'm really weary of this threadbare and moth eaten topic.

Frankly, if Star Trek was ever socially relevant it ceased to be so before it even made it back to TV with TNG. Many 80s sitcoms touched on more social issues than Trek did.

Effectively, the gay argument in the US is OVER. National polls show that the majority of the US populace doesn't just support gay rights, a majority now support marriage equality. These are not numbers set in amber. The acceptance of gays shifted by double-digit numbers in the past decade, and this trend shows no sign of reversing. The younger generation supports gays even more broadly, so this isn't going to change any time soon. If anything, the next generation (pun intended) is going to grow up with gay people as part of day to day life in a way they've never been before, and they're going to see it as completely normal.

In light of this, Star Trek's no longer got any excuse, any more than it would if it had a lily white cast. Fan arguments that they should "take it slow" or that "it doesn't matter" are throwbacks to a bygone age that most of the nation has already said "good riddance" to.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:29 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.