The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek Movies XI+ (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=50)
-   -   In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=206959)

Cadet49 March 23 2013 04:59 AM

In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
In Star Trek 09, why did Sulu use a fold out sword instead of his phaser against the Romulans when he and Kirk boarded the drill? Kirk had his phaser knocked out of his hand, but Sulu would still have his - why kill the Romulans with his sword, when he could stun them with his phaser? You could argue that the dampening field that was interferring with transporters and communications affected phasers as well, but tge Romulan energy guns seemed to work just fine...

J. Allen March 23 2013 05:12 AM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Quote:

Cadet49 wrote: (Post 7838233)
In Star Trek 09, why did Sulu use a fold out sword instead of his phaser against the Romulans when he and Kirk boarded the drill? Kirk had his phaser knocked out of his hand, but Sulu would still have his - why kill the Romulans with his sword, when he could stun them with his phaser? You could argue that the dampening field that was interferring with transporters and communications affected phasers as well, but tge Romulan energy guns seemed to work just fine...

Because it was close quarters combat, Sulu had combat training and, more importantly, he wanted to show everyone his giant fold out sword. :ouch:

Pavonis March 23 2013 05:13 AM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
His sword was out to cut the chute lines that were pulling him into one of those fire-belchers. After that, it was already out, and combat was already underway. No time to switch weapons.

Awesome Possum March 23 2013 05:13 AM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Rule of Cool

M'Sharak March 23 2013 06:14 AM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Quote:

Pavonis wrote: (Post 7838275)
His sword was out to cut the chute lines that were pulling him into one of those fire-belchers. After that, it was already out, and combat was already underway. No time to switch weapons.

This.

JuanBolio March 23 2013 10:51 AM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
More importantly, why didn't Kirk use his phaser as soon as the first romulan popped out of the hatch? Instead of drawing and firing at an easy target, he charges across the platform and attempts to use his helmet as a weapon, resulting in loss of said phaser. Why would anyone trained in basic military tactics do this?

Shazam! March 23 2013 11:13 AM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Because Sulu used a sword that one time.

Tosk March 23 2013 12:45 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
He did it for the same reason that neither Vulcan or Earth had anything available to destroy the drill with.

Flake March 23 2013 02:33 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Shortly after he left the shuttle and was plummeting toward the drill platform Sulu had an awful realisation. When he went to the weapons locker before he boarded the shuttle he accidentally picked up a phaser from the 'malfunctioning pile'. He realised that if he actually pressed fire on this phaser it would overload and blow his hand off, so he left it alone.

BillJ March 23 2013 02:40 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Quote:

Awesome Possum wrote: (Post 7838278)
Rule of Cool

This. :techman:

C.E. Evans March 23 2013 07:37 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Quote:

JuanBolio wrote: (Post 7838914)
More importantly, why didn't Kirk use his phaser as soon as the first romulan popped out of the hatch? Instead of drawing and firing at an easy target, he charges across the platform and attempts to use his helmet as a weapon, resulting in loss of said phaser. Why would anyone trained in basic military tactics do this?

I'm inclined to think that phasers have to be turned on when drawn from a holster. Having them turned off when holstered may be akin to them having a safety engaged.

Maybe if they didn't have to spacedive, they could have went in with phasers at the ready...

Nerys Myk March 23 2013 09:01 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
This

Quote:

Shazam! wrote: (Post 7838956)
Because Sulu used a sword that one time.

And this.

Quote:

Awesome Possum wrote: (Post 7838278)
Rule of Cool


CorporalClegg March 23 2013 09:36 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Maybe Abrams is a member of the sword lobby?

T'Girl March 23 2013 10:04 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
Love the way Sulu with sword in hand, removes his helmet, fits his hair, and then fights the Romulan.


C.E. Evans March 23 2013 10:16 PM

Re: In Star Trek 2009, why didnt Sulu use his phaser on the drill?
 
^^^
He doesn't fits his hair, but he does remove the black skull cap that he and the others wore under their helmets.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:46 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.