The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Enterprise (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=37)
-   -   "Exile"...I hate when... (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=205747)

Dale Sams March 11 2013 04:23 AM

"Exile"...I hate when...
 
...I see an episode and my brain raises a hugely obvious question, and yet the episode doesn't raise it. So I go to read Jammer's review...and HE doesn't ask the question. So I think maybe he just missed it, so I'll read the comments. Nope.

So I'll ask here: Why the **** didn't anyone think to ask this guy living alone, in exile, who goes a century without anyone to talk to....IF HE WANTS TO GO WITH THEM????

Sure, *I* can fanwank a dozen reasons he can't go, but it's not my job to answer obvious questions*

*Unless I just happened to miss a line explaining why he can't go.

Bry_Sinclair March 11 2013 06:30 AM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
They could at least have given Hoshi a super hot alien stud to try and woo her (you know if it's been a Malcolm story she'd have been human-looking and wandered around in the flimsiest of clothing).

Though I believe you are right, I don't recall any of them even consider offering him a way off the planet--think how handy a powerful telepath would have been on their mission.

teacake March 11 2013 10:22 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
They were scared of him. He's way too unpredictable and just plain alien to them to consider it.

bluedana March 12 2013 01:30 AM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
I think that's it. Plus, he was creepy -- the way he wouldn't take no for an answer, and obviously had no problem violating Hoshi's space. Not a guy I'd want to invite on my save-Earth-or-else mission.

Use of Time March 13 2013 02:45 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
Just watched this episode and was thinking the same thing. They could have at least dropped him off somewhere.

dub March 13 2013 04:01 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
I just recently watched this episode. As I watched, I thought maybe the alien caused the shuttlepod thrusters to ignite randomly (using his obviously powerful telepathy). I also briefly considered perhaps he was the cause of the anomalies. Of course, I was proven wrong.

Dale Sams March 13 2013 04:15 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
There were a lot of little things I liked about it. The continuing idea that the smallest thing going wrong (small in the sense that TNG could handwave it away in six different ways) can really leave them effed, such as the shuttle pod bit. And that rather than demonstrate a TNG level of outrage, they chose to have Hoshi exhibit mild discomfort at her invasion of privacy. And eventually just letting the guy ramble when politely pointing out said discomfort didn't work.

edit: I'm annoyed with myself that back in the day I hated Enterprise without giving it enough of a chance.

Christopher March 13 2013 05:44 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
Quote:

Dale Sams wrote: (Post 7785775)
...I see an episode and my brain raises a hugely obvious question, and yet the episode doesn't raise it.

The episode that does that for me is TNG's "When the Bough Breaks." It treats the Aldeans' inability to have children as some insoluble problem where the only choices are to kidnap children or die as a race... and it never once occurs to anyone that there must be plenty of orphans and other children put up for adoption all over the Federation, children who would've gladly volunteered to be adopted by the Aldeans rather than needing to be taken against their will. That was a simple, obvious solution to the whole problem, an easy way to convince the Aldeans that they didn't have to keep the children they'd taken, but nobody ever thought of it. Not to mention that it would've been a good, socially positive message for the episode to call attention to the benefits of adoption.

Use of Time March 13 2013 06:18 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
Quote:

Christopher wrote: (Post 7796842)
Quote:

Dale Sams wrote: (Post 7785775)
...I see an episode and my brain raises a hugely obvious question, and yet the episode doesn't raise it.

The episode that does that for me is TNG's "When the Bough Breaks." It treats the Aldeans' inability to have children as some insoluble problem where the only choices are to kidnap children or die as a race... and it never once occurs to anyone that there must be plenty of orphans and other children put up for adoption all over the Federation, children who would've gladly volunteered to be adopted by the Aldeans rather than needing to be taken against their will. That was a simple, obvious solution to the whole problem, an easy way to convince the Aldeans that they didn't have to keep the children they'd taken, but nobody ever thought of it. Not to mention that it would've been a good, socially positive message for the episode to call attention to the benefits of adoption.

Man that is so simple and yet I never though of that.

I'm going off memory here so correct me if I'm wrong. Didn't they cherish their privacy to the point where they only interacted with the Enterprise because they stumbled upon their planet.

Granted, thats assuming that the survival of their race might at some point include breaking cover and sending people to the adoption agency.

Christopher March 13 2013 08:06 PM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
^Right -- at that point they'd already made contact anyway, so what did they have to lose?

And even if the Aldeans had had some reason to refuse the offer, it's implausible that nobody on the Enterprise even thought to suggest it.

Gaith March 16 2013 02:45 AM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
Quote:

Dale Sams wrote: (Post 7785775)
...I see an episode and my brain raises a hugely obvious question, and yet the episode doesn't raise it. So I go to read Jammer's review...and HE doesn't ask the question. So I think maybe he just missed it, so I'll read the comments. Nope.

Richard Whettestone's got you covered. ;)

Yeah, I skipped this ep in my trip through the expanse, and don't regret it. "A Hoshi ep" was the first bad sign. "A Beauty and the Beast riff" was the second. "It adds basically nothing to the story" was strike three, and, just like that, "Exile" was out. :p

teacake March 16 2013 02:54 AM

Re: "Exile"...I hate when...
 
I liked Exile because it was weirdly creepy and quite un-Trek in some ways.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.