The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Merlin's Series Finale (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=199315)

Kelthaz January 5 2013 05:21 AM

Merlin's Series Finale
 
Merlin’s 5 year run came to an end nearly two weeks ago and there’s not a single topic on it? Come on, I know Merlin has a few fans on this board.

Anyway, I thought The Diamond of the Day was a fitting end to the mediocrity that was Merlin. Merlin's reach has always exceeded its grasp and that is most evident when the show attempts to go for a serious tone. Mordred and Morgana's anticlimactic deaths and the poorest excuse for an epic battle that I've seen outside of Married With Children really goes to show that this show doesn’t know how to do dramatic. Although Merlin reigning thunderbolts on Morgana's army was awesome.

Where the show truly excels is in its interpersonal relationships. The best scenes in Merlin weren’t the battles or the plots (lol), but the smaller, intense moments between the characters. I can barely remember a single plot from the first four years of the show, but I’ll never forget Gaius finally confronting Uther or the dozen great father and son moments between Uther and Arthur. And the best of these relationships is obviously the bromance between Merlin and Arthur. The writers knew why the fans were watching and wisely devoted nearly the entire final episode to Merlin and Arthur alone in the woods. This isn’t HBO though, so it was just lots of talking.

I could go on for a while about the failings of the plot, but that wasn’t the focus of the episode. The focus was on Merlin and Arthur and I don’t have any complaints about that. Merlin’s tearful confession, Arthur’s slow realization of everything that Merlin has done for Camelot without recognition, Merlin’s absolute refusal to give up on his friend despite the odds, and Arthur’s final words of “Thank You” to Merlin were just perfect. Yeah, it was obvious that Arthur was going to die in the end, but that doesn’t change how heartbreaking it was to see Merlin lose his best friend – his destiny. Colin Morgan really knows how to cry. This was probably the saddest series finale I’ve seen since “Sleeping in Light”.

T J January 5 2013 10:17 PM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
It had it's ups and downs, some nice moments to be sure.

Now I want a sequel set in the future (maybe 2150ish) where Arthur returns, is constantly befuddled by how things have changed and Merlin showing him how things are now... or then.

Honestly, if he has to return make it funny!

Guy Gardener January 6 2013 09:29 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
His argument shouldn't have been "Please accept me" it should have been "Change the damn law"

Did they know the show was cancelled when they made the final episode because, if they're given another season by surprise (it happens) they would completely have to change the wardrobe department.

DalekJim January 6 2013 09:31 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
Haha. Oh, Merlin. The show where nothing happened or progressed for 5 years.

Guy Gardener January 6 2013 09:43 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
10 years.

There was a 5 year skip between season 4 and 5.

Bob The Skutter January 6 2013 09:51 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
Quote:

Guy Gardener wrote: (Post 7494595)
His argument shouldn't have been "Please accept me" it should have been "Change the damn law"

Did they know the show was cancelled when they made the final episode because, if they're given another season by surprise (it happens) they would completely have to change the wardrobe department.

It wasn't cancelled, they decided to end it on a high. Though they had originally planned to do 5 years they were asked to do a 6th and the cast turned it down, apparently.

Guy Gardener January 6 2013 09:55 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
Suicide.

that makes a nice change.

Deckerd January 7 2013 12:05 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
There wasn't any suicide. Or am I being dense?

Relayer1 January 7 2013 12:15 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
Quote:

T J wrote: (Post 7492816)
Now I want a sequel set in the future (maybe 2150ish) where Arthur returns, is constantly befuddled by how things have changed and Merlin showing him how things are now... or then.

Camelot 3000 - a 12 issue DC Comics series by Barr and Bolland.

Guy Gardener January 7 2013 12:23 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
Quote:

Deckerd wrote: (Post 7497358)
There wasn't any suicide. Or am I being dense?

They chose to finish the show of their own accord, which was their choice. Following the metaphor, they had a non resuscitation order and then resisted unwanted and uncalled for cpr, because the cast turned down season 6.

Rather then a suit walking in and saying you're all fired, we hate you, sod off, which would be murder.

I wish I knew who the hell stole my Camelot 3000?

It's not that they really really stole it.

They borrowed it, then put it under something and it just became lost. Out of sight out of mind, and even if they did realize that they had it, and how miffed I am after 15 years, they still wouldn't give it back until after they read it which they can't until after they found it... I hate my friends.

Blamo January 7 2013 12:39 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
It was an pretty good finale for a show that had become rather dismal.

When the show first started, Richard Wilson commented on the whole Merlin Vs Doctor Who by saying that unlike Doctor Who, Merlin had a lot more room to change and evolve. Even though I was a Doctor Who fan I agreed with him. There was just so much dramatic potential in Merlin and it was a brand new show.

Shame it didn't live up to it. Heck, it didn't even come close. After a while the show was living just on the supposed bromance and whatever excuse they could find to get someones shirt/armour off.

Doctor Who has now been going on for 7 years and out of the two shows it's the one that feels dramatic and takes chances. Even RTD's cartoony Master was more 3-dimensional then the comic strip villian that Morganna had become.

lennier1 January 7 2013 05:23 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
Glad they finally put it out of its misery!

The show had some great moments, but when they drew out Gwen's brainwashing for wayyyyyyyy too long, I just couldn't stomach it anymore, even with the finale right around the corner.

Starkers January 7 2013 10:54 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
I enjoyed it, and had a lump in my throat but it did feel a bit rushed (I'm not entirely sure I buy the "We always planned 5 years" argument) Mordred and Morgana deserved better send offs really, and I found it a bit sad that Gwen didn't really get a proper goodbye with Arthur, nor Gaius with Merlin.

As always Colin and Bradley played it perfectly, and I'll be honest, Arthur dying did surprise me a little, given the show has played fast and loose with mythology over the years I half expected them to have Arthur survive.

Merlin's been a fun show for 5 years though, and whilst it's never reached the heights it could have done (I'd have loved a final series with Merlin 'outed') I will miss it.

Guy Gardener January 7 2013 11:55 AM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
If Agravaine hadn't been so rash, there's no way that a serving girl would have been able to hold the kingdom together without some royal baby in her, and really with Arthur gone, all the local princes would be lining up to fill'er'up.

Did I miss the hint that Arthur knocked her up?

Taking the adultery out of Gwens story line opens the kindom up to a potential thousand years of prosperity if she can keep her shit together, especially if Merlin backs her up.

Deckerd January 7 2013 02:27 PM

Re: Merlin's Series Finale
 
I'm still tickled about people grumbling that the show played 'fast and loose with the mythology' as if there were some kind of definitive source.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.