The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=197536)

Ian Keldon December 16 2012 09:49 AM

Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
TEOTWAWKI books, films, etc have never been more popular, and I think I know why. I see a LOT of crossover between Poc fans and "preppers". I've visited a few prepper sites, and listened to preppers talk. I know a few preppers, even.

One of the themes that comes up over and over and over in a lot of prepper circles is a certain barely hidden sense of anticipation over the idea that our civilization could collaspe either from within or without, resulting in the deaths of the overwhelming majority of the population...except for those virtuous souls of course who are "prepared". Everyone else? The world is better off w/o them.

Are any of your "preppers"? Are you also Poc fans? Do you know any? Would they, if they were honest, agree with what I said?

JoeZhang December 16 2012 12:10 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

except for those virtuous souls of course who are "prepared".
Except... the key feature in a lot of those works is that the protagonist is completely unprepared because they miss (via plot device) the start of the end of the world - 28 days later and the walking dead are maybe the most popular of the current way and they both start like this (in turn borrowing from day of the triffids and other cosy catastrophe works).

Kegg December 16 2012 01:18 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

JoeZhang wrote: (Post 7405711)
Except... the key feature in a lot of those works is that the protagonist is completely unprepared because they miss (via plot device) the start of the end of the world

Precisely. Zombie apocalypse and/or apocalypse stories tend not to be about people who have been waiting for the inevitable, but ordinary people who have risen to the occasion. Walking Dead's protagonist was a cop, Falling Skies' a history professor.

And sometimes they make the point that misanthropic behaviour, though couched in language of being the 'right' thing to do, can just be the self-justifying ranting of a disturbed mind.


There is a whole fandom built around the question of 'what if' there was a zombie apocalypse and 'being ready' for it, which is just an odd hobby, I guess.

Derishton December 16 2012 03:01 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Wouldn't narratives about people who are unprepared but who succeed through a sharp learning curve be exactly the kind of narratives preppers would like? We don't always seek out stories that are exactly what we expect, but stories that are sideways to them: cautionary tales, stories that paradoxically confirm the need to prepare by showing someone who is not prepared (but who has secret reserves of strength and resourcefulness which allow him or her to prosper against the odds, while everyone else dies around them).

George Steinbrenner December 16 2012 06:50 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
I never did much care for all this zombie crap. It's all the same - zombie apocalypse breaks out, everyone either dies or becomes a zombie (or both), end of show or film. By definition, zombie shows and films can never end well, so I don't like 'em.

The only exception is Philip Nutman's novel Wet Work. I would love to see this filmed. The difference in this one is, there are different 'stages' of dead, if that makes any sense. Some of the zombies are slow (and dumb), some are fast (and still dumb), and some even retain their full intelligence, consciousness and personality - they are, basically, just like living people; except, well, they eat brainz and all that. These smart zombies even take over the government, which they rename the 'United States of Hell'.

Robert D. Robot December 16 2012 11:18 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
^Are these smart zombies available any time soon to take over from the slow, dumb zombies that we have in office now who are currently holding up government from functioning?

Kegg December 16 2012 11:56 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Derishton wrote: (Post 7406020)
Wouldn't narratives about people who are unprepared but who succeed through a sharp learning curve be exactly the kind of narratives preppers would like?

Oh absolutely. It's pretty obvious that zombie survivalists enjoy zombie fiction. But I don't think necesarily that kind of fiction validates misanthropic behaviour - it can, but it need not.

Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 7406524)
The only exception is Philip Nutman's novel Wet Work. I would love to see this filmed. The difference in this one is, there are different 'stages' of dead,

So basically Matheson's I Am Legend.

Ian Keldon December 17 2012 12:59 AM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
I'm not saying that it "validates" misanthropy. I'm just reporting that I see what appears to be a correlation between a love of Poc fiction and a general shall we say "jaundiced" view of civilization.

Yminale December 17 2012 01:19 AM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Ian Keldon wrote: (Post 7405489)
Are any of your "preppers"? Are you also Poc fans? Do you know any? Would they, if they were honest, agree with what I said?

1. Yes
2. NO
3. Yeah too many
4. I would say the Christians/Racists are the worse but they are the minority. One of the thing about prepping is you find out you are not alone and that forming a group/community is essential for survival. What I find weird is that there aren't many generalist. It's either they are prepping for some extreme natural disaster (flood, mega quake, mega volcano) or plague or nuclear war or the economic collapse of society. Honestly your chance of surviving something that big is close to ZERO even if you are prepared. I know some "zombie" preppers. Real nice people with a good attitude and always open to suggestion.

Me I prepp for the small things, blizzards, power outages, epidemics stuff that require you to survive for less than 3 weeks.

Yminale December 17 2012 01:25 AM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Ian Keldon wrote: (Post 7407874)
I'm not saying that it "validates" misanthropy. I'm just reporting that I see what appears to be a correlation between a love of Poc fiction and a general shall we say "jaundiced" view of civilization.

There was an essay I think on IO9 that discussed this topic. It's strange but apocalyptic fiction is popular with both liberals and conservatives. Probably because both groups think that society is completely screwed up and they are both moral absolutists. Plus as a bonus, in the post-apoc world they can established society as it should be.

Reality is going to be like the "The Road" except a million times worse. Modern humans are not capable of surviving without civilization. So called survialist don't the have skills or the experience the ancient hunter-gathers had.

doubleohfive December 17 2012 03:38 AM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Ian Keldon wrote: (Post 7407874)
I'm not saying that it "validates" misanthropy. I'm just reporting that I see what appears to be a correlation between a love of Poc fiction and a general shall we say "jaundiced" view of civilization.

Yeah, but you're coming at it from an extremely closed-minded and two-valued perspective. To you, it has to be either one thing or the other, without any room for compromise, and that's disingenuous and hardly fair to assume.

I'm honestly not saying that to be insulting; its just been my experience thus far that you make up your mind about something and then can't be swayed no matter how reasonable, plausible or just obvious the evidence/argument may be.

I myself was completely nonplussed by the idea of The Walking Dead until this past summer when I finally sat down to watch it; it's now one of my favorite shows. Not because it's about zombies (which I don't really care for, to be honest) or because its a post-apocalypse show, but because of the characters themselves and how they handle their predicament each week. Rick, Carl, Daryl, Merle, Michonne and Andrea are endlessly interesting to me in therms of what drives them while people like Shane, the Governor, Dale, Lori et al each have their own agendas or motivations and whether or not they coincide with everyone's primary goal - survival - is fun to watch.

I do not believe at all zombie fiction or "end of the world" stories are indicative or a leaning toward misanthropy at all. As we have seen it (this subgenre) is not for everyone, and that's ok. If you don't like it, that's not a bad thing nor does it mean that I'm a misanthrope because I enjoy it.

Ian Keldon December 17 2012 03:34 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Yminale wrote: (Post 7408000)
Quote:

Ian Keldon wrote: (Post 7407874)
I'm not saying that it "validates" misanthropy. I'm just reporting that I see what appears to be a correlation between a love of Poc fiction and a general shall we say "jaundiced" view of civilization.

There was an essay I think on IO9 that discussed this topic. It's strange but apocalyptic fiction is popular with both liberals and conservatives. Probably because both groups think that society is completely screwed up and they are both moral absolutists. Plus as a bonus, in the post-apoc world they can established society as it should be.

That last sentence is I think the key. Maybe I've just encountered the "fringes" of the Prepper movement, but I really do get the sense that they really want some sort of apocalypse to happen so that they can do exactly that.

Quote:

Reality is going to be like the "The Road" except a million times worse. Modern humans are not capable of surviving without civilization. So called survialist don't the have skills or the experience the ancient hunter-gathers had.
This I think is true. I know I won't be there to find out (being an insulin-dependent diabetic with physical problems means I'll be among the first to die should the SHTF).

THE Robert Maxwell December 17 2012 06:40 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
I enjoy apocalyptic/post-apocalyptic fiction (books, TV shows, movies, video games, etc.) but I am not a survivalist, I don't want to see civilization destroyed, and I'm not a misanthrope. It's just fantasy. It's a way to take characters out of a typical contemporary setting without stretching one's suspension of disbelief as much as, say, a space opera or high fantasy.

Kegg December 17 2012 06:51 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Robert Maxwell wrote: (Post 7410901)
It's just fantasy. It's a way to take characters out of a typical contemporary setting without stretching one's suspension of disbelief as much as, say, a space opera or high fantasy.

Quite.

The thing about a zombie apocalypse in particular is it's very low on the fantasy spectrum. It's not alien races and new worlds or elves and dragons, it's the world we know having collapsed on itself. Suspension of disbelief is required but the characters are much closer to us than they would be in many other SF&F settings. I think that's an enormous part of the appeal.

Yeah, they're not the original hunter gatherers, even if fate requires them to live not much better than those. But neither are we.

THE Robert Maxwell December 17 2012 07:06 PM

Re: Is Zom-poc/post-apoc the genre for misanthropes?
 
Quote:

Kegg wrote: (Post 7410967)
Quote:

Robert Maxwell wrote: (Post 7410901)
It's just fantasy. It's a way to take characters out of a typical contemporary setting without stretching one's suspension of disbelief as much as, say, a space opera or high fantasy.

Quite.

The thing about a zombie apocalypse in particular is it's very low on the fantasy spectrum. It's not alien races and new worlds or elves and dragons, it's the world we know having collapsed on itself. Suspension of disbelief is required but the characters are much closer to us than they would be in many other SF&F settings. I think that's an enormous part of the appeal.

Yeah, they're not the original hunter gatherers, even if fate requires them to live not much better than those. But neither are we.

Exactly. It's much more relatable. "That could be me, out of my depth, trying to fend off zombies!"

I do think the OP is taking his premise a bit too far, in thinking that enjoying a particular kind of fiction means you'd actually like to see it come to fruition. As a counterexample, a lot of people enjoy high fantasy, with kings, magic, dragons, powerful guilds, and all that jazz. Does that mean people who enjoy it really do support monarchy and mysticism, and wish giant lizards would rain fire upon us all? Of course not.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:01 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.